Consultation on a York Wide Smoke Control Area (SCA)
ApprovedExecutive13 papers
AI summaryCity of York Council Executive unanimously approved expanding the Smoke Control Area to cover the whole city, with no new budget needed, to cut PM2.5 pollution from domestic solid fuel burning.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedDelegate authority to make new SCA order covering all of York
MoneyNo new budgetManaged within existing resources and current staff
What happens nextOrder to be made by DirectorComes into effect at least 6 months after making
Who it affectsAll wards in YorkReplaces current patchwork covering 80% of homes, 14% of area
What was decided
The Executive unanimously considered the public consultation results and full comments on a draft order to expand the Smoke Control Area to the whole of the council's administrative area, revoking historical orders. Report P19
Authority was delegated to the Director of Environmental and Regulatory Services, in consultation with the Director of Governance, to approve making the City of York Council Smoke Control Order (2025) under Option A. Report P20
The new order will come into effect on a date not less than 6 months after the date of making the order. Report P20, P45
Why
A York-wide SCA would provide a mechanism to manage the burning of the most polluting solid fuels and the appliances they are burned in, protecting the health of all residents from PM2.5 pollution. Report P23, P26
It would ensure a consistent approach to smoke emissions across all current and future residential areas, ending the current position where rules differ by area or even within the same street. Report P24, P25, P8
It would complement wider air quality measures, support national PM2.5 targets under the Environment Act 2021, and demonstrate the council is using best endeavours to reduce particulate emissions. Report P9, P10, P38, P80
What happens next
The Director of Environmental and Regulatory Services will, in consultation with the Director of Governance, approve making the new order as drafted at Annex F and revoke historical orders covering the existing area. Report P20, P77
The order will not come into effect for at least 6 months after being made, giving residents a grace period to explore alternative fuels and appliances. Report P45, P70
Environmental Protection will work with the council's communications team on a media campaign to raise awareness, including for local solid fuel suppliers, and update the council's website and GIS mapping. Report P6, P110, P114
The money
£1.6 billion Estimated NHS and social care cost of PM2.5 and NO2 air pollution between 2017 and 2025 Report P31
29,000 to 43,000 deaths per year UK mortality burden equivalent of air pollution at typical ages Report P31
Options considered
Chosen: Option A: Make a new order designating the whole of CYC's administrative area an SCA and revoke existing orders. Provides consistent coverage, controls polluting fuels across all of York, supports national PM2.5 targets and is proportionate Report P78, P79, P80, P82
Rejected: Option B: Make a new order with modifications to geographic boundary, classes of building or fireplace exemptions. Would leave a patchwork of SCAs, would not protect all residents equally, and would be harder to enforce and understand Report P81, P82
Rejected: Option C: Do not approve revocation of existing orders and a new city-wide order. Would leave 20% of existing residential addresses and all undeveloped areas uncovered, and could be seen as not using best endeavours to reduce PM2.5 Report P82, P83
Implications
Financial: No significant budget implications: making the order, publicising requirements and any enforcement will use existing officer time and current staff in Environmental Protection. Report P17, P85
Legal: The council has discretion under Section 18(1) of the Clean Air Act 1993 to declare its area an SCA; the order can be challenged by judicial review. Report P87, P90
Legal: Existing orders made before 13 November 1980 require a separate revocation procedure with Secretary of State confirmation. Report P91
Equalities: An Equalities Impact Assessment has been carried out at Annex E; vulnerable groups including older people, children, pregnant women and those with respiratory illness are more affected by PM2.5. Report P66, P103, P106
Staffing: No HR implications; any future additional resourcing for increased complaint handling would follow normal council policy. Report P86
Climate: The proposal supports CYC's carbon reduction programme; wood burning releases more CO2 than oil or gas for the same heat and emits methane and black carbon. Report P97
Risk: Some low-income households may burn non-compliant solid fuels for financial reasons; the council will take a proportionate, case-by-case approach and signpost residents to support. Report P12, P50, P71
Who and where
Residents outside the current SCA boundary, including outlying villages such as Skelton, Poppleton, Earswick, Strensall, Stockton on the Forest, Dunnington, Copmanthorpe and Bishopthorpe Report P36
All York residents using solid fuel stoves or open fires, including an estimated 39 rural homes using wood as their main heating source Report P103
York-based suppliers of solid fuels Report P56
DEFRA, York Travellers Trust, neighbouring local authorities, and parish councils, who were notified of the consultation Report P56, P58
Vulnerable groups including older people, children, pregnant women and those with respiratory or other illnesses Report P66, P106
Timeline
July 2024: CYC's Fourth Air Quality Action Plan (AQAP4) adopted by Executive, committing to review the SCA boundary Report P13, P28
19 November 2024: Executive Member for Environment and Climate Emergency approved a revised SCA enforcement approach with civil penalties Report P13
22 April 2025: Public consultation launched, with statutory notice in the London Gazette and York Press on 8 and 15 April 2025 Report P51, P52
3 June 2025: Public consultation closed after a 6-week period Report P48
3 March 2026: Executive meeting considered consultation results and approved Option A Report P1
Not less than 6 months after the order is made: New Smoke Control Order to come into effect, revoking historical orders Report P20, P45
Plain English for the jargon
SCA: Smoke Control Area: an area where people and businesses must not emit smoke from a chimney attached to a building
PM2.5: Fine particulate matter up to 2.5 microns across; can enter the lungs and bloodstream and is harmful to health
DEFRA exempt appliance: A stove or boiler that has passed tests showing it can burn inherently smoky solid fuel such as wood without emitting smoke
Authorised smokeless fuel: A solid fuel that is permitted to be burned in an SCA, for example in a non-exempt open fire or stove
AQAP4: City of York Council's Fourth Air Quality Action Plan, adopted in July 2024
COMEAP: Committee on the Medical Effects of Air Pollutants, an independent expert committee advising UK government
Clean Air Act 1993: The Act under which local authorities can declare, vary or revoke Smoke Control Areas
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item208
Resolved
Resolved (unanimously): That Executive a) Considered the consultation summary (Annex C to the report) and full comments (Annex D to the report) received in relation to the public consultation on a draft order to expand the SCA to cover the whole of CYC’s administrative area (and associated revocation of historical orders covering the existing area). b) Delegates authority to the Director of Environmental and Regulatory Services, in consultation with the Director of Governance, to approve the making of the ‘City of York Council Smoke Control Order (2025)’ (as drafted at Annex F to the report) to come into effect on a date not less than 6 months after the date of making the order (Option A as set out in the report) Reasons: A York-wide SCA would: 1) Provide a mechanism to manage both the burning of the most polluting solid fuels and the appliances in which they are burned across the whole of York, thereby protecting the health of all residents. Burning non-authorised fuels contributes to air pollution and especially PM2.5 across the city which harms public health. 2) Ensure consistency in CYC’s approach to dealing with smoke emissions across York, including future residential areas. 3) Ensure clear rules for burning solid fuels (which are currently different depending on the area of York and in some cases even on the same street). 4) Complement wider air quality improvement measure being implemented by CYC and contribute to national emission reduction targets.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
Meeting: Executive Meeting date: 3 March 2026 Report of: Director of Environmental and Regulatory Services Portfolio of: Councillor Jenny Kent, Executive Member for Environment and Climate Emergency
Decision Report: Consultation on a York Wide Smoke Control Area (SCA) Subject of Report 1. Burning solid fuels is one of the most polluting methods of domestic heating1. Wood burning has increased in popularity in recent years for aesthetic as well as practical and economic reasons. Burning of solid fuels, however, is a major contributor to a type of pollution called fine particulate matter (PM2.5), both indoors and outdoors. It is estimated that in 2023, the rate of exposure to PM2.5 experienced by our population in York lead to the equivalent of 1 in every 23 deaths (4.4% of all mortality)2. 2. This report outlines the results of a public consultation on proposals to further reduce emissions of PM2.5 and other pollutants from solid fuel burning through a York wide Smoke Control Area (SCA). The proposals will enable CYC to manage more effectively the burning of the most polluting solid fuels and the appliances they are burnt in. 3. A York wide SCA would replace the current piecemeal orders (see Annex A) which cover 80% of York’s residential properties but only 14% of CYC’s administrative area. Further developments allocated in the Local Plan mean that more properties will be built outside of York’s SCA and therefore not subject to smoke control legislation.
1 Chief Medical Officer’s (CMO) ‘Annual Report (2022): Air Pollution 2 https://fingertips.phe.org.uk/profile/public-health-outcomes-
framework/data#page/3/gid/1000043/pat/6/par/E12000003/ati/302/are/E06000014/iid/93861/age/230/ sex/4/cat/-1/ctp/-1/yrr/1/cid/4/tbm/1 Latest data available is 2023 4. SCAs are areas where people and businesses must not emit smoke from a chimney attached to a building. Under the proposals: Seasoned wood/logs would need to be burned in DEFRA3 approved ‘exempt appliances’ (such appliances have passed tests to confirm that they are capable of burning inherently smoky solid fuel such as wood, without emitting smoke). Residents and businesses can continue to use non-approved stoves and open fires, but may only burn authorised ‘smokeless’ fuels to minimise the release of smoke. Controlled solid fuel (e.g. wood / logs) for use in a building, fireplace, fixed boiler or industrial plant to which a smoke control area applies must not be sold, unless it is to be burned in a DEFRA approved ‘exempt’ appliance. 5. It is important to note that the proposed York wide SCA will not ban domestic solid fuel burning, but will require all of York’s residents to take responsibility for the fuel they burn, so as to minimise smoke and outdoor and indoor air pollution. Judging by the consultation responses detailed in this paper, this distinction may not have been fully understood, and thus this report again sets out the proposed rules under which an SCA will operate and how the council will continue to support residents in understanding the purpose of the intervention, as well as the practical implications of the proposals. 6. Locations outside the current SCAs account for approximately 35% of the properties in York using solid fuel for secondary heating (i.e. to supplement other forms of heating, for example gas central heating) (see Annex A, Figure A2). 7. The proposals would complement CYC’s ongoing DEFRA funded ‘Fuel for Thought’ campaign to raise awareness of the links between burning solid fuels, pollution and health.
8. The public consultation revealed a lot of confusion about the legal requirements within an SCA and whether the respondent was in an SCA or not. The proposals would ensure consistency across York and that all future development sites are subject to smoke control requirements; reduced PM2.5 levels in York would support national priorities for reducing pollution from domestic solid fuel burning, as
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.