What was decided
The Executive considered the consultation representations and approved making the permanent ATTRO in the form set out in Annex C. [D] [P34] [P38] Report P34, P38
The Executive delegated activation, following a Police recommendation, to the Chief Executive. [D] [P35] Report P35
The Executive approved development and implementation of an agreed activation framework. The Chief Executive will work with the Leader and relevant Executive Members. [D] [P36] Report P36
Why
The Chief Constable of North Yorkshire Police recommended that the Council consider a permanent ATTRO. [P7] [P37] Report P7, P37
The Council considered the statutory consultation responses and all other relevant considerations. [D] [P37] Report P37
A permanent order would provide a standing legal framework, allowing quicker activation without processing a new temporary order each time. [P11] Report P11
What happens next
Make the permanent ATTRO in accordance with Annex C. [D] [P34] Report P34
Develop and implement the activation framework with the Leader and relevant Executive Members. [D] [P36] Report P36
On a Police recommendation, officers will review the area to activate and required communications. The Chief Executive will then approve activation. [P14] [P35] Report P14, P35
Options considered
- Chosen: Implement the permanent ATTRO and delegations as proposed. The wider area has previously needed temporary orders, and a standing framework would reduce operational delay. [P52] [P53] Report P52, P53
- Rejected: Limit the ATTRO to areas with permanent hostile vehicle mitigation. Temporary measures would still be needed outside permanent HVM coverage, including for the Minster area. [P53] [P54] [P55] [P56] Report P53, P54, P55, P56
- Rejected: Keep using temporary ATTROs without a permanent order. This requires repeated agreement and Executive decisions, consumes more time and resources, and leaves access and planning concerns unresolved. [P56] [P57] [P58] [P59] [P60] Report P56, P57, P58, P59, P60
Implications
- Financial: Making the permanent order and framework will use existing service budgets and should cost less than repeated temporary orders. [P31] Report P31
- Financial: The Council remains liable for ATTRO costs unless it charges the beneficiary, but it cannot charge organisers of a public event or assembly. [P20] [P33] Report P20, P33
- Legal: An ATTRO can only be made for terrorism purposes and on the Chief Constable’s recommendation, using the statutory traffic order procedure. [P8] [P61] Report P8, P61
- Equalities: The Police and Council must complete a balancing exercise covering the Public Sector Equality Duty and Human Rights rights, including Articles 2, 8 and 14. [P23] [P27] [P61] Report P23, P27, P61
- Risk: A permanent order does not change the number of restricted events or incidents, or the restriction level for a specific incident. It reduces vehicle borne threats but does not remove every attack risk. [P19] [P20] [P44] [P45] Report P19, P20, P44, P45
- Staffing: No human resource implications were identified. [P61] Report P61
- Other: No procurement, health and wellbeing, environment and climate, affordability, or personal data implications were identified. [P61] Report P61
- Other: A communication plan and template communications would support advance notice and planning where warning is possible. [P18] [P49] [P61] Report P18, P49, P61
Who and where
- City centre users in all wards Report P61
- People and businesses in the Guildhall Ward area Report P61
- Residents and businesses in the extended area Report P45, P46
- Blue Badge holders Report P42, P43
- Event organisers Report P18, P32, P59
- Visitors Report P18, P50
- Public event and assembly organisers Report P20, P33
- People using the Minster and the Gardens Report P50
Timeline
- 12 October 2023: The Executive approved starting development and consultation for an ATTRO. [P7] [P38] Report P7, P38
- June 2025: The Executive Member for Transport approved undertaking the statutory consultation. [P40] Report P40
- 18th March 2026: The statutory consultation was advertised to Blue Badge holders, residents and businesses. [P41] Report P41
- 9 September 2026: The Executive approved the permanent ATTRO and related delegations. [P2] [D] Report P2
- On receipt of a Police recommendation: The Chief Executive will decide whether to activate the permanent ATTRO. [D] [P35] Report P35
Plain English for the jargon
- ATTRO: A special legal order allowing the Council and Police to restrict vehicle and pedestrian access to reduce terrorism danger. [P8]
- Permanent ATTRO: A standing order that remains legally in place but is normally dormant until activated. [P11]
- Temporary ATTRO: An order for one specific short term event or incident, then ending after it. [P10]
- HVM: Hostile Vehicle Mitigation, protective measures against hostile vehicles. [P43] [P53]
- NYP: North Yorkshire Police. [P7]
- PSED: Public Sector Equality Duty, requiring consideration of effects on protected groups. [P17] [P61]
- Chief Constable: The Police officer whose recommendation is required before an ATTRO can be made. [P8] [P61]
- Chief Executive: The Council officer delegated to approve activation after a Police recommendation. [D] [P35]