What was decided
The Executive approved changing the Minster Badge from the current charge of £45 for two years to an annual charge of £15. [D] It also approved increasing the community parking discount for badge holders from 30% to 50%. [D]
The Executive continued to use parking charges to influence travel behaviour and support the Local Transport Strategy goal of moving away from private cars. [D] Blue Badge holders will continue to receive free unlimited parking. [D]
The Executive noted that parking strategy work will sit within the wider Movement and Place Plan and kerbside strategy. [D] It approved informal consultation before significant parking charge increases and supported a more detailed annual parking account report. [D]
Why
The decision acknowledges feedback and recommendations from the independent review of petitions in four areas. [D][P4][P37] Report P4, P37
Parking charges remain a lever to reduce car journeys and support public transport, walking and cycling under the Local Transport Strategy. [P16][P17][P35] Report P16, P17, P35
The changes balance access for local shops with transport objectives. [P15][P36] The review was limited to petitioned areas and used surveys with stated limitations. [P48][P49][P50][P51] Report P15, P36, P48, P49, P50, P51
What happens next
The Council will develop the parking strategy within or alongside the Movement and Place Plan. It will consider parking near places of worship and other important destinations. [D][P111][P116] Report P111, P116
The changes will not be implemented immediately. The Council will publicise them and update parking software, payment systems, signs and its website first. [P106] Report P106
The Council will consult informally before significant parking charge increases and publish a revised annual parking account with more detail on revenue and reinvestment. [D][P123][P131] Report P123, P131
The money
- £15 Approved annual Minster Badge charge Report P102
- 50% Approved discount in community parking areas Report P103
- £45 for two years Previous Minster Badge charge Report P102
- 30% Previous Minster Badge community parking discount Report P103
- £3/hour to £1.50/hour Community parking rate for Minster Badge holders Report P103
- £22k Assumed income reduction from the lower badge price Report P31
- £7,000/year Estimated revenue impact of the larger discount Report P32
- £80 to £150k High level parking strategy cost estimate Report P32
Options considered
- Chosen: Lower the Minster Badge price. It offers targeted support for residents while keeping the badge digital and vehicle specific. Report P102
- Chosen: Increase the Minster Badge community parking discount. The rate for badge holders falls from £3/hour to £1.50/hour in the listed community areas. Report P103
- Chosen: Continue free unlimited parking for Blue Badge holders. It maintains the Council's existing parking policy. Report P149
- Chosen: Develop a city parking strategy. The Local Transport Strategy and its Implementation Plan already commit to this work. Report P110, P111
- Chosen: Consult informally before significant parking charge increases. It provides feedback for assessing impacts and informing decisions. Report P123
- Chosen: Publish a more detailed annual parking account report. It will show parking and enforcement revenue and how it is reinvested. Report P131
- Rejected: Change the equity impact assessment process. Human rights and equity impact analysis is already part of decision making. Report P118, P119
- Rejected: Change the national Blue Badge scheme. The Department for Transport sets eligibility and national concessions, so the Council cannot change the scheme. Report P120
Implications
- Financial: The Council's budget assumes £11.2m from off street and on street car parking charges. [P139] The proposals could reduce revenue by circa £18k, but no budget change is proposed at this stage. [P139] Report P139
- Financial: The parking strategy will use transport budgets and Combined Authority funding. [P32] Its high level cost estimate is £80 to £150k, depending on scope and data needs. [P32] Report P32
- Staffing: The informal consultation and revised parking account will require additional staff time. [P33] The report identifies no human resource implications. [P140] Report P33, P140
- Legal: The Council must publish a notice of variation in a local newspaper for 21 days and display it prominently in car parks. [P141] Report P141
- Equalities: The human rights and equity assessment found low mixed impacts. [P146] Reduced prices can help badge holders access selected areas, while people without a badge may face negative impacts. [P147] Report P146, P147
- Climate: Lower charges may cause a small rise in car use and vehicle emissions. [P143][P144] The impact should be limited because only selected community areas are covered. [P144] Report P143, P144
- Risk: Lower charges may slow the shift to sustainable transport and delay Local Transport Strategy and climate targets. [P154] The new consultation will delay significant charge decisions and require extra resources, but may reduce the risk of a Traffic Management Act challenge. [P33][P156] Report P33, P154, P156
- Other: Lower charges may increase footfall and dwell time in affected locations, although the economic effect should be limited. [P152] Significant communications support will be needed for the badge changes, consultation and parking strategy. [P151] Report P151, P152
Who and where
- Current and prospective Minster Badge holders Report P102, P104, P106
- Blue Badge holders Report P149
- York residents without a Minster Badge Report P147
- Traders and businesses in the four reviewed areas Report P37, P92
- Residents and visitors in the four reviewed areas Report P90, P93
- Shops and services served by community car parks Report P63, P65
- People needing to reach places of worship Report P116
- Wider York communities affected by travel and emissions Report P143, P144
Timeline
- July 2024: The Executive adopted the Local Transport Strategy. Report P19
- February 2025: The Executive recommended budget changes to car parking and on street parking charges. Report P20
- April 2025: New parking charges were implemented. Report P38
- June and July 2025: The right to challenge petitions were submitted. Report P38
- December 2025 to March 2026: The independent review consultation took place. Report P45
- June 2026: The review findings were presented to the Place Scrutiny Committee. Report P52
- 9 September 2026: The Executive made the parking charge, strategy and reporting decisions. Report P1
- by 2030: The Local Transport Strategy targets a 20% reduction in miles driven, increasing the use of public transport by 50% and doubling the amount of active travel. Report P20
Plain English for the jargon
- LTS: Local Transport Strategy, which sets transport objectives and targets. [P5][P20]
- Minster Badge: Digital, vehicle specific parking permit available to York residents. [P5][P102]
- Community parking: Community and suburban car parks plus listed community on street areas. [P63][P103]
- Blue Badge: National parking concession scheme administered locally by the Council. [P120]
- ResPark: Residents' priority parking scheme giving eligible permit holders priority in zones. [P66]
- Movement and Place Plan: Wider work on reallocating road space and balancing travel corridors with public spaces. [P111]
- Kerbside strategy: Strategy looking at all uses of the highway. [P32]
- Right to Challenge: Traffic Management Act 2004 petition route for reviewing parking policies. [P4][P43]