CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Bristol City Council
Cabinet, Tuesday 23 January 2024 at 4.00pm

Bristol Avon Flood Strategy Outline Business Case

Approved Executive 5 papers

Cabinet approved this item on Tuesday 23 January 2024. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item15

Resolved

That Cabinet: 1. Approved the Outline Business Case and notes and approves its submission to the Environment Agency for its assurance review. 2. Noted the capital cost for delivery (in 2028 present value terms) of Phase 1 construction is estimated at £255m, of which approximately £251m (also in 2028 present value terms) of funding through Defra’s Flood Defence Grant in Aid, WECA’s Economic Development Fund, council reserves and Community Infrastructure Levy is identified in principle. 3. Authorised the Executive Director for Growth and Regeneration, in consultation with the S151 Officer and the Cabinet Member for Finance, Governance and Performance, to apply for and enter into agreements or contracts to spend grant funding of £2.2m Local Levy raised by the Wessex Regional Flood and Coastal Committee in support of the delivery of the Full Business Case and supporting activities. 4. Authorised the Executive Director for Growth and Regeneration, in consultation with the S151 Officer and the Cabinet Member for Finance, Governance and Performance, to apply for and enter into agreements or contracts to spend funding of up to £10m from the West of England Combined Authority, in support of the delivery of the Full Business Case and supporting activities. 5. Authorised the Executive Director for Growth and Regeneration, in consultation with the S151 Officer and the Cabinet Member for Finance, Governance and Performance, to enter into agreements or contracts to spend the council’s capital reserves (as previously allocated to the delivery of the strategy) in support of the delivery of the Full Business Case and supporting activities.
Word for word from the decision Bristol published for this meeting. Source: democracy.bristol.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Bristol's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet

BRISTOL CITY COUNCIL

Bristol Avon Flood Strategy Outline Business Case

Bristol Avon Flood Strategy OBC | P04 – For cabinet approval | 09 January 2024 | Ove Arup & Partners Limited Page | ii Bristol City Council (supported by the Environment Agency and WECA) Contents

1.0Executive Summary 1 1.1 Strategy objectives 1 1.2 Strategic case 2 1.3 Economic case 6 1.4 Commercial case 10 1.5 Financial case 11 1.6 Management case 13 1.7 Project statistics for EA assurance 14 2.0 Strategic Case 18 2.1 Introduction 18 2.2 Strategic Context 23 2.3 Environment and other considerations 28 2.4 Consenting 31 2.5 Need for intervention 33 2.6 Supporting development 36 2.7 Other sources of flooding 36 2.8 Strategic objectives 37 2.9 Current arrangements 38 2.10 Main benefits 43 2.11 Main risks 44 2.12 Constraints 46 2.13 Dependencies 46 2.14 Interfaces with other projects 48 3.0 Economic Case 55 3.1 Introduction 55 3.2 Critical success factors 55 3.3 Long list options 56 3.4 Shortlist options 60 3.5 Economic appraisal 64 3.6 Environmental appraisal 75 3.7 Non-financial benefits appraisal 78 3.8 Strategy Carbon Impact 79 3.9 Preferred option 80 3.10 Residual risk 91 4.0 Commercial Case 94 4.1 Procurement strategy and timescales 94 4.2 Efficiencies and commercial issues 102 5.0 Financial Case 104

Bristol Avon Flood Strategy OBC | P04 – For cabinet approval | 09 January 2024 | Ove Arup & Partners Limited Page | vii Bristol City Council (supported by the Environment Agency and WECA) 5.1 Summary of financial appraisal 104 5.2 Identified funding sources 110 5.3 Expenditure and income profile 110 5.4 Funding strategy 113 6.0 Management Case 118 6.1 Project Management 118 6.2 Schedule 123 6.3 Outcomes 125 6.4 Risk, assumptions, issues and dependencies management 127 6.5 Assurance 129 6.6 Communications and stakeholder engagement 131 6.7 Next steps 131 7.0 Glossary 133

Tables Table 1 - Properties at risk of flooding in 0.5% AEP tidal or 1% AEP fluvial events in the Do-Minimum status quo baseline (Avoids double counting and is not properties claimed in the Partnership Funding Calculator) 4 Table 2 - Present Value damages, benefits and whole life costs of baseline and do- something options of Standard of Protection (SoP) considered by economic appraisal. * IBCR compared with 1.33% AEP SoP 8 Table 3 - Summary of cost and funding position 12 Table 4 - Partnership funding scores 12 Table 5 - Summary of project costs for preferred option 14 Table 6 - Schedule of critical milestone dates 17 Table 7 - Properties at risk of flooding in 0.5% AEP tidal or 1% AEP fluvial events in the Do-Minimum status quo baseline (Avoids double counting and is not properties claimed in the Partnership Funding Calculator) 33 Table 8 - Key risks, consequences and proposed responses 46 Table 9 – Critical success factors 56 Table 10 – Summary of long list measures 60 Table 11 – Shortlist of strategic options taken forward 61 Table 12 – Summary of economic benefits of options 70 Table 13 - Summary of NPV costs for each option 71 Table 14 - Benefit cost ratios for each option 72 Table 15 - Payment for outcomes from the Partnership Funding Calculator 72 Table 16 - Potential local benefits of the Strategy 74 Table 17 - Summary of proposed defences. *indicates height above existing defence rather than height above ground level. 84 Table 18 - Climate change scenarios 93 Table 19 - Procurement options 98 Table 20 - Contract strategies 101

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
App A: BAFS Outline Business Case January 2024Appendix 6.5 MB DownloadRead as text
PDF
App D: BAFS Delivery Risk RegisterAppendix 98 KB Download
PDF
App E: BAFS Equality Impact AssessmentAppendix 102 KB Download
PDF
App F: BAFS Environmental Impact AssessmentAppendix 140 KB Download
PDF
Bristol Avon Flood Strategy Outline Business CaseDecisions 164 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

9 of 20 attended
MB
Councillor Marley BennettCommittee Member, present
MJ
Mette JakobsenCouncil Staff, expected
RY
Richard YoungCouncil Staff, expected
AH
Alex HearnOfficer, expected
MR
Marvin ReesCommittee Member, apologies
DA
Councillor Donald AlexanderCommittee Member, present
NB
Councillor Nicola BeechCommittee Member, present
CC
Councillor Craig CheneyCommittee Member, present
AC
Councillor Asher CraigCommittee Member, present
KD
Councillor Kye DuddCommittee Member, present
HH
Councillor Helen HollandCommittee Member, present
EK
Councillor Ellie KingCommittee Member, present

All 20 on the meeting page

On this subject at Bristol

Search all
  1. Bristol Avon Flood Strategy Outline Business CaseThis decision
  2. Bristol Avon Flood Strategy Funding StrategyApproved
  3. Bristol Avon Flood StrategyApproved
  4. Application Number 16/04561/F - Linear Park, Avon Street, BristolAgreed

More from Bristol Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
9 Apr 2024 Single Homelessness Accommodation Programme (SHAP) Funding BidThat Cabinet: 1. Authorised, the Executive Director of Growth and Regeneration, in consultation with the Cabinet Memb... Decided Open
9 Apr 2024 Temporary Accommodation UpdateThat Cabinet: 1. Approved the Full Business Case at Appendix A and exempt appendix I and the allocation of the capita... Approved Open
9 Apr 2024 Safety Valve Programme – capital fundingThat Cabinet: 1. Noted the full terms of the Safety Valve agreement with the Department for Education (DfE) (Appendix... Noted Open
9 Apr 2024 TIBCO Maintenance ContractThat Cabinet: 1. Approved the re-procurement of a compliant maintenance contract for TIBCO for a period of 3 years a ... Approved Open
9 Apr 2024 Hybrid Meeting Technology and Audio-Visual UpgradesThat Cabinet: 1. Authorised the Director – Policy, Strategy and Digital in consultation with the Deputy Mayor – Finan... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies