Cabinet: 1. Noted the outcome of the consultation; and 2. Approved the proposal to alter the upper age range at Manchester Mesivta Secondary School from 11-16 year olds to 11 - 18 year olds in order to add 6th form provision with effect from September 2023.
Word for word from the decision Bury published for this meeting.Source: councildecisions.bury.gov.uk
1.1In accordance with the School Organisation (Prescribed Alterations to Maintained Schools) (England) Regulations 2013, Cabinet is requested to determine a proposal published by the Governing Body in respect of Manchester Mesivta Secondary School regarding a prescribed alteration to change the age range of the school.
1.2The current provision comprises a local authority maintained 11-16 secondary school, and an independent 6 th form provision funded by the Education & Skills Funding Agency (ESFA), through a sub-contracting arrangement facilitated by Bury College. There are approximatley 50 students in the 6 th form.
1.3The ESFA has indicated that it intends to withdraw from such sub- contracting arrangements, and the proposal presented to Cabinet is intended to ensure continuity of funding for the 6 th form by incorporating it into the maintained school.
1.4As with the 11-16 school, the 6 th form serves boys from the Orthodox Jewish community, provision that is not available elsewhere.
1.5It is proposed to alter the upper age range at Manchester Mesivta Secondary School from 11-16 year olds to 11 - 18 year olds in order to add 6 th form provision with effect from September 2023.
1.6The Governing Body of Manchester Mesivta Secondary School has published the proposal and has consulted upon that proposal.
1.7Ordinarily, and taking into account Department for Education guidance on school organisation matters, Officers would be recommending refusal of the proposal on the basis of its size, and given the current Ofsted rating for the school which is ‘Requires Improvement’. DfE suggest a minimum of 200 pupils, and only making such changes when provision is judged to be good or better.
1.8There are, however, exceptional circumstances in this instance. The 6 th form has been in place for many years, and has continued to deliver positive educational outcomes. On the basis of the ESFA funding arrangements it has also demonstrated that it is financially viable. 1.9 The proposal, whilst making a statutory change, will not impact on the way the 6 th form operates, and there is nothing to suggest that the educational outcomes and financial viability will be impacted by the proposed changes.
1.10However, robust arrangements are already in place to enable the local authority to support schools, and hold them to account, which is designed to mitigate any potential risk. These arrangements will be extended to cover the 6 th Form.
1.11Conversely, if the Council was not minded to support the proposal, the implication is that the 6 th form provision would cease, significantly disadvantaging the community, with no comparable provision available to meet the needs to students from the Orthodox Jewish community.
1.12On balance therefore, Officers are recommending that the proposal is supported.
1.13Under the same sub-contracting arrangements, state funding is currently provided to Shalsheles which is an independent 6 th form provision located in Manchester and which serves girls from the same Jewish community. As an independent provision, Shalsheles is not governed by the same regulations as Mesivta and ESFA has been able to confirm the continuation of the existing state funding arrangements.
2.0Recommendation(s)
That:
Cabinet notes the outcome of the consultation.
Cabinet approves the proposal to alter the upper age range at Manchester Mesivta Secondary School from 11-16 year olds to 11 - 18 year olds in order to add 6 th form provision with effect from September 2023.
2.1Reasons for recommendation(s)
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.