Officer’s recommendation overturned – application REFUSED The proposal is inappropriate development in the green belt, and insufficient very special circumstances have been demonstrated, contrary to Policy C5 of the Core Strategy, and NPPF Policy 89.
Word for word from the decision Dacorum published for this meeting.Source: democracy.dacorum.gov.uk
The site comprises of the hotel, its grounds and a lowly occupied very poorly maintained mobile home park within the Green Belt.
The proposed redevelopment provides an opportunity to establish a modern replacement hotel at the site and to temporarily rehouse the occupiers of the existing mobile homes.
Following previous unacceptable schemes for new hotel accommodation over many years and extensive pre application and post submission dialogue, the hotel has now closed. This was during the period following the receipt of a modified scheme with ongoing consultation at the end of 2014.
In terms of Green Belt policy the site is regarded as previously developed land providing an opportunity for redevelopment. However, a comparison between the existing form of development and the application scheme confirms that the proposal is inappropriate development in the Green Belt . It is therefore by definition harmful and has to be considered on the basis of the applicant’s very special circumstances.
The applicant’s pre closure planning supporting statement comprehensively explains the very special circumstances. This should now be considered in the context of the implications of the closure and the opportunity to reinvigorate the site through the proposal. There will be expected resultant economic benefits to the Borough to justify the redevelopment. The development's scale is necessary to satisfy the owner’s operational requirements.
The approach to design is fundamentally different to the existing. It makes a ‘bold cutting edge design statement’ in its rural context as an alternative to the current very tired ad hoc array of uncoordinated range and sprawl of buildings. The proposed design is key to the site’s revitalisation, providing a positive alternative to the traditional approach to design with a more compact building footprint.
Subject to the imposition of a wide range of conditions the application is recommended for permission. As a departure to Green Belt policy it is necessary to refer the application to the Secretary of State.
Description
The 46 bedroom Bobsleigh was a long established and expanded Hotel located on the classified Hempstead Road to the north east of the village of Bovingdon. The site (1.9 h) lies within the Green Belt in the open countryside within a wooded setting. It occupies an elongated (120m) and prominent frontage to Hempstead Road with buildings and car parking aligned along its entire length, separated by a wide grass verge with bus stops on both sides of the highway. There are detached dwellinghouses located opposite also within a wooded setting. Stable Cottage (used for staff accommodation) and Highcroft Farm (a dwelling and a converted outbuilding for two dwellings) are located to the immediate north east . There are fields to the south west and south east. The south western field was subject to a refusal of planning permission for Travellers. Highcroft Trailer/ Caravan/ Mobile Home Park is located behind the site frontage buildings. It is now in a semi derelict condition with two of the 11 homes occupied. It adjoins the hotel gardens, preserved trees and an ice house. There are 3 accesses linked to Hempstead Road. The hotel’s main access is located centrally linked to the frontage car park. A secondary access is at the northern end. The mobile home park is served by a separate roadway from the site's northern access onto Hempstead Road.
Proposal Background
The application in its Original and Revised Forms is supported by a wide range of documents including:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.