Officer’s recommendation overturned – application REFUSED The applicant has not demonstrated a full commitment to marketing the vacant retail units for their intended and permitted A1, A2 or A3 uses. The loss of floorspace for these retail uses would have a harmful effect on the vitality and viability of this part of Hemel Hempstead Town Centre, contrary to Policies CS16 and CS33 of the core strategy. The proposal is also contrary to Policy CS4 of the Core Strategy, which seeks a mix of uses in town centre locations, and Policy CS13 which seeks pedestrian friendly, shared spaces, in appropriate location
Word for word from the decision Dacorum published for this meeting.Source: democracy.dacorum.gov.uk
The application was considered at the Development Control Committee of 28th May 2015 where the Committee resolved to defer making a decision on the application to await further information from the applicant regarding the marketing of the units, the offer price of the floorspace and the prospects of attracting retail tenants in this location. Information was also sought on the precise location of the car parking spaces for the proposed residential units.
Members should consider the updated information below together with the previous committee report from the 28th May 2015 meeting.
Further submitted information from applicant
The following additional information has been submitted:
1. A letter from Lambert Smith Hampton (see Appendix 1) which reiterates the principal challenges related to letting the units alongside confirmation of the price per sq ft being sought and how this compares with lettings secured in the main town centre over the same period. It demonstrates that whilst the podium units have been marketed based on a rent which is discounted compared with the core town centre, they have remained vacant with little interest generated;
2. An additional letter from local commercial agency Brasier Freeth (see Appendix 2) which sets out their position regarding the attractiveness of the units on the podium from a local agency perspective;
3. Also attached are extracts of various email correspondence (see Appendix 3) over the marketing period which demonstrates the following:
(a) Invitations to high street names to attend a preview event for the units which are turned down; (b) E-mails from the LSH agent expressing frustration at a potential deal falling through due to competition of Jarman Park; (c) Interest from a pharmacy which fell away due to a rejected application to the relevant issuing body; (d) Evidence of Hemel Hempstead not being an attractive location; (e) Concerted efforts by the Applicant to secure lettings including responding to speculative applications placed by prospective tenants in the property press; (f) Evidence of the units still being marketed in March 2015.
The applicant also makes some further comments as follows: It is noted that whilst the table in the committee report states ‘lack of parking’ as one of the key concerns of prospective retail tenants, this is not due to no car parking space being offered, as each unit is provided with spaces as per the original consent, but that tenants want more than one space which we cannot physically offer given the finite number of spaces delivered with the scheme. As a point of clarification, whilst the retail car parking spaces are currently occupied by other commercial tenants, this is only to ensure they do not sit idle whilst the units are vacant and are available for immediate use by any future retail tenant should the units be successfully let; The reference to "rent too high / fit-out-works too expensive" relates more to lack of finance by the prospective tenants than a comment on the market rate being asked; We have undertaken a pedestrian count of the podium vs. the main town centre with the results confirming the significant lack of footfall compared with the town centre. The results of this are included in the LSH letter (see Appendix 1).
Further Officer Considerations
The above further information from the applicant demonstrates the particular difficulties of finding tenants for these retail units in the Image development.
Footfall is particularly weak as demonstrated by the survey results from 2nd June 2015:
Podium 10 am - 11 am - 34 people 12 am - 1.30 pm - 177 people
Riverside 10 am - 11 am - 597 people 12 am - 1.30 pm - 1,492 people
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.