Resolved
Officer’s recommendation overturned – application REFUSED The proposed development fails to reflect the character of the neighbourhood, and the setting of the nearby heritage asset, contrary to Policies CS11 and CS 27 of the Core Strategy.
Development Management refused this item on Thursday 18 June 2015. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
Officer’s recommendation overturned – application REFUSED The proposed development fails to reflect the character of the neighbourhood, and the setting of the nearby heritage asset, contrary to Policies CS11 and CS 27 of the Core Strategy.
The application is recommended for approval.
The site is situated within the urban area of Hemel Hempstead, in Character area HCA 7: Boxmoor wherein residential development would be acceptable in principle in accordance with Policy CS4 of the Core Strategy and saved Policy 10 of the Local Plan. The development principles for HCA 7 identify that a range of dwellings styles are acceptable.
Old Fishery House is a relatively large detached house that has evolved in phases since the late C18th or early C19th and occupies a secluded position on the east side of Old Fishery Lane. The house sits close to the road with an extensive garden running down to the river and canal beyond. Several outbuildings cluster the frontage adjacent to the Lane. The property is considered worthy of local listing but is currently an 'undesignated heritage asset'. National and Local planning policy seeks to protect the setting of heritage assets and consideration must therefore be given to the impact of the proposed new dwellings on the setting of this important historic building.
The proposal would impact on the setting of the existing building. However, it is considered that the level of harm caused to its setting would not be significant enough to warrant a refusal. Although the setting of a heritage asset would be harmed, the merits of this scheme are balanced in favour of its approval for the following reasons;
The new properties are set some distance within the plot allowing the main house and its outbuildings to remain the dominant building across the site. There would therefore remain a hierarchy in the buildings across the site, the new dwellings appearing as subservient, set back structures in comparison to the prominent historic building . The height of the proposed dwellings has been lowered, again to respect the hierarchy across the site, Limited visibility - the new dwellings would only be visible from immediately in front of the access drive, from all other public vantage points they would largely be screened from view. On the other hand, Old Fishery House and its outbuildings sit very close to the road and as such are imposing buildings in the street scene (most of the properties in this section sit a little back from the road, especially on the eastern side of the Lane). The proposal would not change the overall street scene in a significant manner. Old Fishery House is set in extensive grounds, such that even with the new dwellings and their respective gardens, a large garden remains to serve Old Fishery House and this extends right up to the canal to the north. It is concluded therefore that the remaining garden would adequately preserve the setting of the building. The new dwellings are situated to the west of the site, within the existing built up area, and in close proximity to surrounding properties; Heron House and the properties of Moorland Road. The east of the site, towards the canal would remain open and undeveloped.
With regard to the design of the dwellings, the site is situated in character area HCA7 wherein a range of house styles are acceptable. On balance the design proposed is considered acceptable in this secluded location. There are other examples of recent dwellings of a range of designs in the immediate vicinity. Despite appearing as tandem development, the layout is in this instance considered acceptable. The site is sufficient in size to accommodate the development proposed and given it would only serve 2 dwellings the access would not cause significant harm in terms of noise or disturbance.
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
5.10 Old Fishery House, Old Fishery Lane, Hemel Hempstead HP1 2BNReport | 230 KB | DownloadRead as text |
Follow Development Management at Dacorum and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.