Officer’s recommendation overturned – application REFUSED The proposal fails to meet appropriate standards of design, on the basis of over-dominance, and the failure to conform to the surrounding character of the area of chalet bungalows, contrary to Policies CS12 and CS11 of the Core Strategy .
Word for word from the decision Dacorum published for this meeting.Source: democracy.dacorum.gov.uk
This application was deferred by Members at their meeting on 9th April 2015 for investigations to be undertaken in relation to the planning history of the site, including alleged refusals on this site.
A full history check of the application site; the rear of 52 & 54 Lockers Park Lane and that of the individual and adjacent sites, No.s 50, 52 and 54 has now been undertaken and is set out below;
4/1552/94 – Two detached dwellings (Outline) – Granted 4/1669/91 – Two detached dwellings (outline renewal) – Granted
No. 52 Lockers Park Lane
4/01496/13/FHA SINGLE STOREY FRONT EXTENSION AND TWO STOREY SIDE EXTENSION. Granted 27/09/2013
No. 54 Lockers Park Lane 4/00534/04/FUL DEMOLITION OF EXISTING GARAGE AND CONSTRUCTION OF DWELLING Refused 21/04/2004
4/00231/75/FUL CAR PORT Granted 30/06/1975
No. 50 Lockers Park Lane
4/01537/92/4 DETACHED DWELLING Granted 27/01/1993
4/01529/91/4 ERECTION OF 4 BEDROOM DETACHED HOUSE Refused 02/01/1992
Considerations
At the last committee and in representations received, residents and the ward councillor drew Members attention to several refusals of planning permission at the site. Planning permission was refused in 2004 for a single dwelling to the rear of No. 54 Lockers Park Lane. This is the only refusal of planning permission in the immediate area. All other applications for additional residential accommodation at this and adjacent sites have been approved. The remainder of the refusals referred to by residents appear to relate to land tribunal appeals (dealing with restrictive covenants) and not planning appeals. The applicants agent has confirmed that the restrictive covenant preventing the construction of additional dwellings has now been lifted from the site. This is not therefore a matter for consideration.
With regard to the planning history of the site, notwithstanding the 2004 refusal, the principle of additional residential accommodation at the rear of the existing dwellings has already been established through the granting of outline planning permission in 1994 and 1991. Furthermore as set out in the original committee report the principle of the development would be acceptable in line with Policy CS4 of the Core Strategy and Saved Policy 10 of the Local Plan.
The main considerations in the determination of the application are thus the visual impact of the new dwellings and their impact on the residential amenity of adjacent properties. These matters have been addressed in the original committee report. In addition, in line with Members previous concerns, it is necessary to compare the refused scheme to that currently proposed.
With regard to the refused scheme it is considered materially different to that current proposed in the following ways; it related to half the current application site only, it proposed a single large, detached, 4-bed single dwellinghouse of significant height and prominent design, which related (in design and form) neither to the one and half storey chalet style dwellings to the north of Park Hill Road, nor the terraced two and three storey properties to the south of Park Hill Road. the rear garden depth was far less than that currently proposed and below the minimum standard required by policies.
Conclusion
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.