AI summaryEast Devon planners approve innovative, highly sustainable rural dwelling at Lily Cottage, All Saints, despite open countryside policy conflict, subject to conditions and a Section 106 agreement on nutrient mitigation.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedApprove, adopt Appropriate Assessment, S106 for drainage
MoneynullNo sums stated in the papers
What happens nextS106 to be completedOff-site phosphorus mitigation and foul drainage upgrade to be secured
Who it affectsSite at All Saints, AxminsterLand at Goldsmiths Lane with ruins of former Lily Cottage
What was decided
The committee adopted the Appropriate Assessment and approved the application in line with the officer recommendation, subject to a Section 106 agreement securing a foul drainage upgrade. Report P133, P134, P135
Condition 10 was amended to require written confirmation before first occupation that specific sustainability measures (heat pump, MVHR, 7.5kWp PV, 13.5kWh battery, bio-based fabric) have been installed and commissioned, and retained for the lifetime of the development. Report P151
Why
The council can only demonstrate a 3.5-year housing land supply, engaging the tilted balance in NPPF paragraph 11(d); a single dwelling may be acceptable in principle despite countryside policy conflicts. Report P84, P125
The Urban Designer judged the revised, lower-scale cob-and-thatch design with bespoke integrated PV eaves to be an attractive, contextually appropriate addition that addresses the dismissed 2022 appeal. Report P52, P53, P54, P55, P93, P95
The dwelling meets NPPF paragraph 139(b) tests for outstanding, innovative, highly sustainable design, attracting significant positive weight, while reliance on the private car causes only limited harm. Report P108, P109, P112, P130, P131
What happens next
Complete the Section 106 agreement to secure off-site phosphorus mitigation through a septic tank upgrade at Myrtle Farm, securing no adverse effect on the River Axe SAC. Report P36, P37, P116, P117
Submit pre-commencement details covering tree protection (BS 5837), surface water drainage, package treatment plant siting, external materials, landscaping and the integrated PV system, then verify sustainability installation before first occupation. Report P138, P143, P144, P145, P147, P148, P151
Submit a final SAP calculation within six months of first occupation confirming the dwelling achieves an A rating and zero-carbon performance. Report P153
Options considered
Chosen: Approve subject to conditions and S106 (officer recommendation). Limited harm from car reliance outweighed by innovative, highly sustainable design meeting NPPF paragraph 139(b). Report P131, P132, P135
Rejected: Refuse. Prior appeal Inspector concerns on scale and dominance resolved by revised, smaller design; parish and objector concerns not sufficient to outweigh benefits. Report P9, P15, P21, P22, P127, P130
Implications
Legal: Permission granted subject to a Section 106 agreement; Appropriate Assessment adopted to satisfy Habitats Regulations in respect of the River Axe SAC. Report P36, P37, P115, P116, P117, P133
Equalities: Officers considered the Human Rights Act 1998 and the Equality Act 2010 public sector equality duty in reaching the recommendation. Report P196, P197
Risk: Nutrient mitigation initially relied on an orchard on a drainage mound, which Natural England considered unsuitable; reliance on a car-dependent rural location flagged by objectors. Report P35, P40, P41, P83
Other: Permitted Development rights removed for outbuildings and for Classes A, B and D enlargements to protect design quality. Report P154, P155, P156
Who and where
The applicant (owner of land at Lily Cottage, Goldsmiths Lane, All Saints) Report P74, P75
All Saints Parish Council (objector) Report P9, P15
Three local objectors raising design, amenity, landscape, ecology, drainage, traffic and waste concerns Report P19, P21, P22, P23, P24, P26, P27, P28, P29
One supporter who considered the design low-impact and well-integrated Report P19, P22
Occupants of The Chestnuts and Chestnut Cottage (immediate neighbours to the south) Report P76, P114
Timeline
12.06.2019: Earlier application 19/0078/FUL refused by the Council. Report P63
22.06.2022: Appeal on 19/0078/FUL dismissed by Inspector. Report P63, P79
02.12.2024: Urban Designer confirms revised PV integration is successful and recommends approval on design grounds. Report P52, P55
19.02.2025: Natural England accepts the Council's Appropriate Assessment conclusion subject to strengthened reasoning. Report P34
27.02.2026: Natural England withdraws objection subject to mitigation secured by S106 (septic tank upgrade at Myrtle Farm). Report P36, P37
24.03.2026: Planning Committee resolves to adopt the Appropriate Assessment and approve with conditions and S106.
Plain English for the jargon
Tilted balance: The test in NPPF paragraph 11(d) applied where a council cannot show a five-year housing land supply, requiring permission unless harms significantly and demonstrably outweigh benefits.
Section 106 agreement: A legal agreement under section 106 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 used to secure planning obligations such as off-site mitigation.
Appropriate Assessment: A Habitats Regulations assessment of a plan or project's effect on a European protected site, here the River Axe Special Area of Conservation.
Nutrient neutrality: Requirement that a development does not add nutrients (such as phosphates) to a sensitive catchment, here the River Axe.
NPPF paragraph 139(b): National policy giving significant weight to designs that are outstanding or innovative, promote high levels of sustainability and fit with their surroundings.
GSHP / MVHR / PV: Ground-source heat pump, mechanical ventilation with heat recovery, and photovoltaic (solar electricity) panels.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item95
Resolved
The Appropriate Assessment be adopted. 2. Approved in accordance with officer recommendation subject to a S106 agreement to secure a foul drainage upgrade and subject to an amendment to Conditon 10 to read as follows: “Prior to first occupation, a written report shall be submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority confirming that the sustainability measures identified in the Design & Access Statement (December 2023), or updated measures or equivalent or superior performance, have been installed and commissioned. These shall include: (a) a low-carbon heating system, such as a ground or air source heat pump, or any alternative technology that achieves equal or greater energy efficiency and carbon savings; (b) a whole-dwelling mechanical ventilation system with heat recovery; (c) an eaves mounted renewable electricity-generating system with capacity equal to or exceeding 7.5kWp installed in accordance with the details under Condition 8; (d) on-site energy storage with capacity equal to or exceeding 13.5 kWh; (e) a breathable, bio-based fabric construction, including hob, straw bale and wood fibre; The approved measures, or approved updated equivalents, shall thereafter be retained and maintained for the lifetime of the development. (Reason – To ensure the dwelling achieves and maintains the very high levels of sustainability that form a key component of the planning balance under NPPF paragraph 139.)
Word for word from the decision East Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.eastdevon.gov.uk
This application is before the committee because it is a departure from the development plan. It seeks full planning permission for the demolition of the remains of the former Lily Cottage and construction of a new dwelling on land at Goldsmiths Lane, All Saints. A previous proposal on the site was refused and subsequently dismissed at appeal, primarily due to excessive scale, dominance and inadequate integration with neighbouring cottages. The current submission has been expressly prepared in response to that decision.
The revised design retains the Inspector-praised sinuous cob-and-thatch concept but significantly reduces height, width and footprint, and incorporates a bespoke eaves-line photovoltaic system that integrates modern technology with traditional materials. The Council’s Urban Designer considers the revised scheme to be an attractive, well-proportioned and contextually sensitive addition.
Although the site lies in the countryside and the proposal conflicts with Strategy 7 and with Strategy 5B/Policy TC2 relating to sustainable travel, the Council’s housing land supply position engages the tilted balance under NPPF paragraph 11(d). The dwelling demonstrates clear innovation in materials and construction and achieves very high sustainability performance, including zero-carbon operation. These attributes attract significant positive weight under NPPF paragraph 139(b).
Technical matters, including ecology, drainage, trees and nutrient neutrality, can be appropriately managed through conditions and a Section 106 agreement securing off-site phosphorus mitigation.
In the overall planning balance, the limited harm arising from reliance on the private car does not significantly and demonstrably outweigh the substantial
23/2663/FUL benefits of delivering an innovative, highly sustainable and contextually sensitive dwelling that resolves the issues identified at appeal. The proposal therefore represents sustainable development when assessed against the NPPF as a whole, and approval is recommended subject to conditions and completion of the Section 106 agreement.
CONSULTATIONS
Local Consultations
Parish/Town Council All Saints Parish Council do not support the application.
The proposed development is on the footprint of a cottage that was replaced by a property known as Poppins and should be treated as a new development.
The proposed development is outside the Defined Settlement Boundary in the East Devon Local Plan 2013-2031.
The proposed development is within the river Axe catchment area which does not allow any new property to increase the phosphate discharge into the river Axe. The Nutrient Neutrality document in the planning application appears to refer to a property "Greenhayes" in certain pages and requires close examination by a competent person.
The proposed development is lower in height and smaller than the development refused at appeal in May 2022, but it is still many times the footprint of the original cottage and larger than the other properties in the vicinity.
This application has been registered many times since 1981 and has been refused each time.
All Saints Parish Council do not support the application as there are no changes to our previous submissions concerning this application.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
26/0534/MOUT (Major) WHIMPLE & ROCKBEAREThe Appropriate Assessment be adopted. 2. Approved with conditions in accordance with officer recommendation subject ...
26/0535/MFUL (Major) WHIMPLE & ROCKBEAREThe Appropriate Assessment be adopted. 2. That the SANGS application be approved, subject to conditions and to the co...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.