AI summaryHigh Peak Borough Council refused planning permission to demolish the Buckingham Hotel in Buxton and replace it with a replica aparthotel, citing heritage harm and bat protection issues.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeRefusedApplication HPK/2025/0158 refused, with delegated authority for wording changes
Money£4,800 offered via s106For 8 replacement trees at £600 each, but refused overall
What happens nextDecision notice to be issuedHead of Development Services may vary wording with Chair
Who it affectsBuckingham Hotel site, Buxton1-2 Burlington Road, SK17 9AS
What was decided
The committee refused the application to demolish the Buckingham Hotel and build a replica aparthotel, with an additional reason that Natural England is unlikely to issue a derogation licence for bats.
Delegated authority was given to the Head of Development Services, in consultation with the Chair, to make minor wording changes to the decision.
Why
Historic England objected that the total loss of the undesignated heritage asset would cause moderate to high less than substantial harm to the Pavilion Gardens and Serpentine Walks Conservation Area and the Grade II* registered park and garden, and that no alternative retention options had been explored. Report P9, P10, P21, P22, P23, P37, P38, P39
The Tree Service did not object in principle but noted the scheme would lose 4 protected trees without replacement, contrary to the local plan's 2:1 replacement ratio. Report P50, P52, P53
An update sheet added that Natural England is unlikely to issue a derogation licence to deal with the presence of bats on the site.
What happens next
The decision notice will be issued, with the Head of Development Services able to vary the wording of conditions, informatives, planning obligations or reasons for refusal in consultation with the Chair, provided changes stay within the substantive decision.
The money
£4800 Section 106 payment for 8 replacement trees at £600 each Report P51
£600 Cost per replacement tree under proposed s106 Report P51
Options considered
Rejected: Approve the application with conditions and a s106 agreement for tree replacement. Heritage harm from demolition of the undesignated heritage asset and lack of bat mitigation outweighed other considerations Report P21, P22, P37
Chosen: Refuse the application with delegated authority for minor wording changes. To allow flexibility on the precise wording while keeping the substantive refusal, including the bat licence reason added on the update sheet
Implications
Legal: Section 72 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 requires special attention to preserving or enhancing the conservation area, and the proposal was found to fail this test. Report P30, P43
Equalities: The building is part of the 19th century expansion of Buxton as a spa town and contributes to local character and distinctiveness; its loss would affect the wider architectural history of the town. Report P15, P16, P17, P18, P21
Environment and climate: Bats on site cannot be mitigated through a Natural England derogation licence, adding a separate environmental reason for refusal.
Financial: A s106 contribution of £4,800 was offered for 8 replacement trees at a 2:1 ratio, but this was not enough to outweigh heritage concerns. Report P50, P51
Risk: The Environment Agency's earlier objection over groundwater in a Source Protection Zone 1 was resolved subject to conditions, with foul drainage going to the mains sewer. Report P1, P2, P3, P5
Who and where
Residents and visitors to the Pavilion Gardens and Serpentine Walks Conservation Area in Buxton Report P8, P18, P22
The applicant seeking to redevelop the Buckingham Hotel site Report P20
Users of the Grade II* Pavilion Gardens Registered Park and Garden Report P8, P22
Timeline
13/01/2022: Earlier application HPK/2020/0352 was refused Report P2
15/06/2022: Environment Agency indicated it would remove its objection if the May 2022 hydrogeology report was submitted Report P2
16.05.25: Historic England summary of its objection Report P7
27.08.25 (revised): HPBC Tree Service revised comments noting loss of 4 trees without replacement Report P46, P50
2025-11-03: Development Control Committee refused the application
Plain English for the jargon
SPZ 1: Source Protection Zone 1: an inner zone around a groundwater abstraction used for drinking water where protection is tightest.
Undesignated heritage asset: A building or site with heritage value that has not been formally listed or designated, but still carries planning weight.
RPG: Registered Park and Garden, graded on the Historic England register, here the Grade II* Pavilion Gardens.
Derogation licence: A licence from Natural England that permits an action that would otherwise be illegal, such as disturbing a protected species like bats.
Section 106 agreement: A planning obligation under Section 106 of the Town and Country Planning Act used to secure contributions or works from a developer.
NPPF: National Planning Policy Framework, the national planning policy guidance in England.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item26/59
Resolved
That the application be refused as set out in the report, subject to an additional reason for refusal that Natural England are unlikely to issue a derogation licence to deal with the presence of bats, as set out in the update sheet; and 2. That in the event of any changes being needed to the wording of the Committee’s decision (such as to delete, vary or add conditions/informatives/planning obligations or reasons for approval/refusal) prior to the decision being issued, the Head of Development Services be delegated authority to do so in consultation with the Chair of the Committee, provided that the changes do not exceed the substantive nature of the Committee’s decision.
Word for word from the decision High Peak published for this meeting.Source: democracy.highpeak.gov.uk
HIGH PEAK BOROUGH COUNCIL DEVELOPMENT CONTROL COMMITTEE
3rd November 2025
Application No: HPK/2025/0158 Location 1-2 Buckingham Hotel, Burlington Road, Buxton, SK17 9AS Proposal Redevelopment of the Buckingham Hotel including demolition of the existing Buckingham Hotel and the erection of a replacement building as an Aparthotel comprising of 53 units. Applicant [name removed] n/a Parish/Ward Buxton Date registered: 29/04/2025 If you have a question about this report please contact: Rachael Simpkin [email protected] 01538 395400 extension 4122
REFERRAL
The full planning application is categorised as a small-scale major.
1. SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDATION
REFUSE
2. DESCRIPTION OF THE SITE AND ITS SURROUNDINGS
2.1The 0.21 ha (hectare) (the previous application stated 0.25 ha) application relates to the vacant Buckingham Hotel which is a large three storey Victorian building in the style of a large villa, dated 1876. It was one of the first buildings to be developed along Burlington Road. The building occupies an important corner plot and serves as a key landmark and pivotal building at the junction of Burlington Road and St Johns Road. The existing building functions as a 37 bedroom hotel with onsite car parking for 31 guest vehicles.
2.2The application site lies within the Buxton Central Conservation area, adjacent to the Buxton Park Conservation Area, and adjacent to the boundary of the Pavilion Gardens and Serpentine Walks Grade II* Listed Historic Park and Gardens within the built up area boundary of Buxton.
2.3The hotel’s origins as two semi-detached villas, believed to be built as hotels, can be seen in its symmetrical design. The pair are believed to have been combined in the early 20th century. The property’s stone construction and Victorian villa design are similar to many other Victorian buildings within Buxton and within the Buxton Park and Central Conservation Areas.
2.4The application site is also located within the Buxton Water Source Protection Area – B. 3. DESCRIPTION OF THE PROPOSAL
3.1The applicant seeks full planning permission for demolition of the existing Buckingham Hotel and its replacement with a new 53 room aparthotel building across all floors, including basement accommodation totalling 2461.0 sqm GIA (Gross Internal Area).
3.2There has been a history of planning applications to demolish this building dating back to 2016 and to build a replacement hotel (initially 110 beds) with stacked basement car parking. All have been refused principally on heritage grounds.
3.3The current submission follows the recommendation of refusal of planning permission ref. HPK/2020/0352 for the ‘Demolition of existing hotel and replacement with a 95 bedroom hotel’ at the 16th August 2021 Development Control Committee meeting. It was subsequently refused on the 13th January 2022 and thereafter dismissed at appeal on the 15th August 2023.
3.4The applicant’s Design, Access and Heritage Statement for the current scheme in relation to the design of both the existing and replacement building discusses the following matters:
- “The length of the main Burlington Road elevation is unchanged. - All the bay window locations are the same as existing. - The length of the St Johns Road elevation is 162 mm longer than existing. - The length of the rear elevation is 1072 mm longer than existing (as the building has been squared off at the south-west corner). - The building position in respect of distances to both roadside boundaries remains unchanged. - Both eaves and roofline heights are unchanged. - Burlington Road fenestration is unchanged. - St Johns Road fenestration is unchanged bar towards the rear where the roof steps up there is an additional window and the door and porch omitted. - Nursery side fenestration is unchanged above ground level bar the addition of three windows plus the lower ground floor central bay window. - Rear fenestration has been reduced from 27 windows to 20”.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.