HPK/2025/0254 - Moor Edge, New Mills Rd, Birch Vale
RefusedPlanning1 paper
AI summaryHigh Peak Borough Council refused planning permission for two open market dwellings at Moor Edge, New Mills Road, Birch Vale, due to harm to a protected Poplar tree and poor living conditions for future occupiers.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeRefusedApplication HPK/2025/0254 refused as recommended
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextDelegated to Head of Development ServicesAuthority to vary wording of decision with the Chair
Who it affectsNot stated
What was decided
The committee refused the application for two residential dwellings as set out in the officer report. Report P4, P5
Authority was delegated to the Head of Development Services, in consultation with the Committee Chair, to make minor wording changes to the decision, provided the substantive nature is not exceeded.
Why
The proposal conflicts with Local Plan Policy EQ9 because the layout creates an unsustainable relationship with protected trees, in particular a 22m tall Poplar (T11) whose canopy would cover the rear gardens and overhang the roofs, leading to inevitable future pressure to prune or remove the tree. Report 7.13, 7.17, 7.19, 7.20, 7.22, 7.30, 7.33, P106
The proposal conflicts with Local Plan Policy EQ6 and NPPF paragraphs on design and amenity because the plot nearest the access has an extremely small rear garden of about 2.5m depth, which combined with constant shading from T11, would provide a poor quality of amenity for future occupiers. Report 7.39, 7.40, 7.41, P192
Officers accepted the design, neighbour amenity, highway safety, ecology, drainage and affordable housing elements of the scheme, but judged the tree and amenity harms to be overriding. Report 7.45, 7.47, 7.62, 7.69, 7.75, 7.83, 7.86, 7.87, 7.89
What happens next
The Head of Development Services may amend the wording of the refusal reasons, in consultation with the Committee Chair, before the decision notice is issued.
If the applicant wishes to pursue the scheme, a revised layout addressing the relationship with T11 and the under-sized garden would need to be submitted. Report 7.30, 7.31, 7.32, 7.33
Options considered
Chosen: Refuse the application (officer recommendation). Conflict with LP Policy EQ9 on protected trees and LP Policy EQ6 on residential amenity for future occupiers Report P4, P5, 7.30, 7.33
Rejected: Approve the application with conditions. Officers judged the harm to the protected Poplar tree and the poor living conditions from the undersized shaded garden to be overriding Report 7.30, 7.33
Implications
Legal: Conflict identified with Local Plan Policies EQ9 and EQ6, and with NPPF paragraphs 135, 136 and 187 on trees, design and biodiversity. Report 7.33, P106
Environment: A Category A Poplar (T11), protected by a Tree Preservation Order and roughly 80 to 100 years old, would be put under long term pressure to be pruned or removed if the dwellings were built as drawn. Report 2.4, P13, 2.5, 7.17, P166, 7.20
Risk: Future occupiers living beneath the canopy would face near constant shade, leaf and honeydew fall, and the possibility of branch failure, creating a likely demand for works to a protected tree. Report 7.20, 7.22, 7.28, 7.29, P110, P113
Other: The site is within the built-up area of Birch Vale, a Smaller Village, and the Council cannot currently demonstrate a five year housing land supply, so the tilted balance in NPPF paragraph 11 applied. Report 2.6, 7.11, 7.12, P151, P152
Future occupiers of the proposed dwellings Report 7.41
Neighbours on New Mills Road (Nos. 87, 89 and 91) and Moor Edge Report 7.44, 7.45, 7.46
A protected Poplar tree (T11) and 12 other trees under a Tree Preservation Order Report 2.3, 2.4, P13, 7.15, P157
Timeline
10th April 2024: HPK/2024/0007 for a two storey rear extension approved Report P27
19th August 2024: NMA/2024/0020 non-material amendment approved Report P28
4th August 2025: Expiry date for neighbour letter comments Report P38
8th August 2025: Application registered and expiry date for site notice comments (14th August 2025) Report P3, P38
17th November 2025: Arboricultural Response to Tree Officer objection submitted Report P22
18th November 2025: Further Response to Tree Officer objection submitted Report P22
8th December 2025: Development Control Committee refuses application HPK/2025/0254 Report P2
Pending: Related application HPK/2025/0253 for two self-build dwellings remains pending Report P29
Plain English for the jargon
TPO: Tree Preservation Order, a legal protection placed on trees.
BNG: Biodiversity Net Gain, a requirement for development to leave biodiversity in a better state than before.
NDSS: Nationally Described Space Standards, minimum space standards for new homes.
AIA: Arboricultural Implications Assessment, a study of how a development affects trees.
SPD: Supplementary Planning Document, guidance supporting Local Plan policies.
NPPF: National Planning Policy Framework, the government's national planning policy.
CIL: Community Infrastructure Levy, a charge on new development to fund infrastructure.
LPA: Local Planning Authority, the council that decides planning applications.
DCC: Derbyshire County Council, the authority providing highway advice.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item26/71
Resolved
That the application be refused as set out in the report; and 2. That in the event of any changes being needed to the wording of the Committee’s decision (such as to delete, vary or add conditions/informatives/planning obligations or reasons for approval/refusal) prior to the decision being issued, the Head of Development Services be delegated authority to do so in consultation with the Chair of the Committee, provided that the changes do not exceed the substantive nature of the Committee’s decision.
Word for word from the decision High Peak published for this meeting.Source: democracy.highpeak.gov.uk
HIGH PEAK BOROUGH COUNCIL DEVELOPMENT CONTROL COMMITTEE
Date 8th December 2025
Application No: HPK/2025/0254 Location Moor Edge, New Mills Rd, Birch Vale Proposal Erection of 2 x residential dwellings at Moor Edge New Mills Road Applicant [name removed] [name removed], Veritas Planning Parish/ward Hayfield / Sett Date registered 8th Aug 2025 If you have a question about this report please contact: James Stannard, Tel. 01298 28400 extension 4298, [email protected]
1. SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDATION
Refuse
1. REASON FOR COMMITTEE DETERMINATION
1.1This application has been brought before the Development Control Committee by Councillor Inman, who wishes for matters relating to Green Belt, Character and Design, Residential Amenity, Flooding and Drainage, and Highway Safety to be fully considered.
2. DESCRIPTION OF THE SITE AND ITS SURROUNDINGS
2.1This application relates to a parcel of land immediately adjacent to an existing detached property known as Moor Edge, accessed via a single access track south of New Mills Road, Birch Vale.
2.2The site currently contains an existing single storey building finished partly in stone and partly in pebbledash render with a slate tiled roof. A secondary structure lies beyond to the south. Both buildings are in a state of disrepair with the secondary building not benefiting from any roof.
2.3An area of hard standing lies to the west off the access track, whilst Moor Edge stands to the east. The rear elevations of existing two storey terraced properties stand to the north, whilst a significant number of trees, many of which are protected by a Tree Preservation Order (TPO) stand to the south, beyond the site boundary but within land controlled by the applicant.
2.4The most notable of these trees is a Poplar Tree (T11 as referenced on the accompanying Tree Survey) which is situated approximately 11m
1 from the rear elevation of the existing buildings referenced above. The Tree Survey notes that this tree has a height of 22m with a crown spread of approximately 12-13m, with a root protection area of 14.4m.
2.5The Tree Survey identifies this as a ‘Category B’ tree. However, as per comments contained within this report, the Council’s Tree Officer strongly disputes this assessment and finds that this tree should be classified as a ‘Category A’ tree.
2.6For the purposes of the Local Development Plan the whole of the application site lies within the built-up area boundary of Birch Vale.
3. DESCRIPTION OF THE PROPOSAL
3.1The application seeks full planning permission for 2no residential open market dwellinghouses with associated parking provision and amenity areas.
3.2The latest plans and documents that are the subject of assessment within this report are as follows:
Plans
- Location Plan (1910.PL10) - Existing Site Layout (1910.PL16) - Existing Elevations (1910.PL14) - Proposed Site Layout and Section (1910.PL12C) - Plans and Elevations (1910.PL18B) - Street Scene Elevation (1910.SK10) - Site Layout with Visibility Splays (1910.SK12A) - Swept Path Analysis New Mills Rd (4553-SP01) - Swept Path Analysis Internal (4553-SP02) - BNG Site Plan
Documents
- Planning Statement - Initial Transport Considerations Note - Preliminary Bat Roost Assessment April 2025 - Bat Activity Survey Report June 2025 - Tree Appraisal - Tree Protection Survey - Arboricultural Impact Assessment - Arboricultural Response to Tree Officer Objection (17/11/2025) - Response to Tree Officer Objection (18/11/2025)
3.3The application and all supporting plans and documents can be viewed online via the following link
Planning Application - High Peak Borough Council
2 4. RELEVANT PLANNING HISTORY
4.1The site has been subject to the following planning history:
HPK/2024/0007 Two Storey Rear Extension (Approved 10/04/2024)
NMA/2024/0020 Non-Material Amendment in relation to HPK/2024/0007 – changes to openings and elevations (Approved 19/08/2024)
HPK/2025/0253 Proposed demolition of bungalow and Erection of 2 x self-build residential dwellings at Moor Edge New Mills Road (Pending)
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.