AI summaryHigh Peak Borough Council has refused planning permission for six dwellings on the Chapel Garage site in Chapel-en-le-Frith, citing loss of an active commercial business and harm to neighbour amenity.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeRefusedHPK/2024/0121 refused by Development Control Committee
MoneyNo money in decisionNo financial sum attached to the refusal
What happens nextDecision can be appealedApplicant may appeal to the Planning Inspectorate
Who it affectsChapel Garage site, Hayfield RoadLoss of operating vehicle repair garage and MOT business
What was decided
The committee refused the application for six dwellings as recommended in the officer report. Report P5
The committee delegated authority to the Head of Development Services, in consultation with the Chair, to make minor wording changes to the decision before issue.
Why
Officers concluded the scheme conflicts with Local Plan Policy E4 because the applicant has not shown the active commercial garage is no longer viable as a going concern, and the site was marketed at inflated prices that included hope value for redevelopment. Report 7.30, 7.31, 7.46, P206, P207, P208, P209, P210, P211, P212, 7.47
The layout would harm residential amenity: the side-to-rear separation of 7.4m between Plots 1 to 3 and Plot 6 was judged overbearing, the new two storey element of Plot 6 would oppress Aspincroft Cottage at 11.9m, and a first floor window in Plot 4 would overlook Nos 2 to 8 Hayfield Road. Report 7.79, P253, 7.80, 7.81, 7.87, 7.88, P265, P266, P267, 7.90
Derbyshire Wildlife Trust advised refusal unless nocturnal bat surveys were carried out before determination, and the requirement for protected species survey work was not met. Report P100, P101, P102, P103
What happens next
The applicant may appeal the refusal to the Planning Inspectorate within the statutory period.
Officers indicated that a revised scheme retaining the existing garage business, similar to the scheme allowed on appeal in 2013, could be supported. Report 7.48
The Head of Development Services may refine the wording of the decision in consultation with the committee Chair before it is issued.
The money
£250,000 Valuation of the business as a going concern, ignoring building values Report P173
£275,000 Value of the buildings sold as one lot Report P174
£335,000 Value of the buildings sold as separate buildings Report P175
£450,000 Value of the site as a development for 6 dwellings Report P176
£642,500 Original market value calculated by applicant's surveyor Jonathan V Davies Report 7.34
£650,000 Initial asking price when first marketed by Gascoigne Halman from March 2023 Report P179, P181, P182
£575,000 Reduced asking price in December 2023 Report P179, P182, P209
£6.25 per square metre Rental value per square metre asserted by Impeys in September 2023 Report 7.40
£38,250 per annum Annual rental value asserted by Impeys in September 2023 Report 7.40
£475,000 Open market sale value from Impeys and later marketing price Report 7.40, P209, P211
£365,000 Independent capital value appraisal by Roger Hannah for the Council Report P202, 7.44, P211
Options considered
Chosen: Refuse the application as recommended by officers. Loss of active commercial garage, flawed marketing, and harm to neighbour amenity Report P5, 7.47, 7.90
Rejected: Approve the application. Conflicts with Local Plan Policy E4 and amenity policies Report 7.47, 7.90, P103
Implications
Legal: The site lies within the Town End Conservation Area, requiring special attention under Section 72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990. Report 7.49
Equalities: Loss of an established local business in the town centre; objections raised by Chapel Parish Council and three residents on parking and highway safety grounds. Report P61, P62, P63, 6.1, P58
Risk: Derbyshire Wildlife Trust advised refusal because no nocturnal bat surveys had been carried out for buildings with moderate bat roost potential. Report P99, P100, P101, P102, P103
Other: The Highways Authority raised no objections subject to conditions, but flagged that two off-street parking spaces may need to be removed if a neighbouring right of access is obstructed. Report P88, P89, P90, P91, P92, P93, P94
Other: Residents at No.128 Market Street asserted a right of access through the site to their rear garage which could be affected by the layout. Report 3.4, P94
Who and where
The applicant, Simon Jones of SJ Design Ltd Report P3
Existing occupiers of Nos 2 to 8 Hayfield Road, who would be overlooked by a first floor window in Plot 4 Report 7.81, P266
Occupiers of Aspincroft Cottage, affected by the new two storey element of Plot 6 at 11.9m separation Report 7.85, 7.87, 7.88, P261
Future occupiers of Plots 1 to 3, facing an overbearing relationship with Plot 6 at 7.4m Report 7.79, P253, 7.80, P265
Chapel Parish Council, which objected on parking, junction safety and loss of industry grounds Report P61, P62, P63
The existing Chapel Garage business and any future proprietor, given the refusal prevents its loss Report 7.23, 7.24
Timeline
27th March 2024: Application registered by the council Report P3
2nd May 2025: Expiry date for neighbour letter comments Report P55
16th May 2025: Expiry date for site notice comments Report P55
18th August 2025: Independent marketing and valuation appraisal by Roger Hannah issued for the council Report 7.43, P192
8th December 2025: Development Control Committee considers and refuses the application Report P2
Plain English for the jargon
BNG: Biodiversity Net Gain, a 10% uplift in habitat value required by the Environment Act 2021
NDSS: Nationally Described Space Standards, the minimum sizes for new dwellings and their rooms
Hope value: Additional value placed on a site because of potential for future planning permission for a more valuable use
B2 Use Class: General industrial use class in the Town and Country Planning Use Classes Order
Class E: Commercial, business and service use class covering shops, offices and some light industrial processes
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item26/72
Resolved
That the application be refused as set out in the report; and 2. That in the event of any changes being needed to the wording of the Committee’s decision (such as to delete, vary or add conditions/ informatives /planning obligations or reasons for approval/refusal) prior to the decision being issued, the Head of Development Services be delegated authority to do so in consultation with the Chair of the Committee, provided that the changes do not exceed the substantive nature of the Committee’s decision.
Word for word from the decision High Peak published for this meeting.Source: democracy.highpeak.gov.uk
HIGH PEAK BOROUGH COUNCIL DEVELOPMENT CONTROL COMMITTEE
Date 8th December 2025
Application: HPK/2024/0121 Location Chapel Garage, Hayfield Road, Chapel-en-le-Frith Proposal Removal of 2 existing buildings, conversion of 2 existing buildings to form dwellings and 4 new dwellings (6 dwellings) Applicant [name removed] Simon Jones, SJ Design Ltd Parish/ward Chapel / Chapel East Date registered 27th March 2024 If you have a question about this report please contact: James Stannard, Tel. 01298 28400 extension 4298, [email protected]
1. SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDATION
Refuse
1. REASON FOR COMMITTEE DETERMINATION
1.1This application has been brought before the Development Control Committee by Cllr Gorlay who has raised concerns in connection with parking, highway safety and the impact on the character and appearance of the area.
2. DESCRIPTION OF THE SITE AND ITS SURROUNDINGS
2.1This application relates to a parcel of land that is currently in active use as a commercial garage (‘Chapel Garage’). It offers a range of services associated with the maintenance of vehicles, operating 6 days a week between the hours of 08:00 and 18:00 Monday – Friday, and 08:00 until 13:00 on Saturdays.
2.2The site benefits from direct access to Hayfield Road, and contains 4no. buildings, identified on the submitted Existing Site Plan as Buildings ‘A’, ‘B’, ‘C’, and ‘D’.
2.3Building ‘A’ comprises a single storey structure with a rectangular form, and is the main repair aspect of the garage business, which is characterised by advertising and signage, containing the customer facing reception, showroom, and workshop, with off-street parking immediately in front of it.
2.4Building ‘B’ is positioned south of Building ‘A’ and the vehicular access to the rear courtyard, set back a noticeable distance back from the public highway, and amounts to a two storey structure constructed of a
1 natural stone with slate tiled roof, which is actively in use as ancillary office and storage space. Further off-street parking exists to the front of this building.
2.5Building ‘C’ is located towards the southern boundary of the site. The building is two storey with a simple rectangular form that is stated as being used as ancillary storage/workshop in connection with the garage. The first floor is accessed via an external stone staircase.
2.6Building ‘D’ is located to the rear of Building ‘A’ and is the least visually attractive of the four buildings, adorning a flat roof and being finished in corrugated metal sheeting. This building is used as a workshop with the front of the building facing outwards into the shared courtyard.
2.7The site lies within the built-up area boundary, the defined Town Centre of Chapel-en-le-Frith and within the Town End Conservation Area.
3. DESCRIPTION OF THE PROPOSAL
3.1The application seeks full planning permission for a new housing development on this site and the resultant loss of the existing commercial garage.
3.2The resultant proposal would be to provide 3no. two storey terraced properties (Plots 1-3) in place of Building ‘A’ fronting Hayfield Road, detached two storey converted properties (Plot 4 and Plot 5) and a final detached property (Plot 6) in place of Building ‘D’.
3.3Properties would be accessed via a shared access utilising the existing access to the rear courtyard serving the existing garage. The Block Plan appears to show allocated parking for 2no. spaces associated with Plots 4, 5 and 6 but no spaces associated with Plots 1-3.
3.4Representations have been received from the occupiers of No.128 Market Street to the south that assert that Title Deeds confirm that they have a right of access through the site to their rear garage.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.