Resolved that - (i) the Amion / BDP Feasibility Study’s recommended option be adopted by the City Council as the basis for pursuing a future role for the former church, and that its delivery (as outlined in section 7.2 of the Study) be authorised to the Planning Manager; (ii) the Planning Manager be authorised to pursue funding sources to progress the above, including the preparation of any bids or applications necessary to do this; (iii) the Planning Manager report back to the Executive Member on the result of bids for funding and the full financial implications of the proposals, together with a timetable for delivery.
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
Purpose of report To up-date the Executive Member in respect of St Luke’s Church following receipt of a Feasibility Study commissioned to consider its future use.
Background
1. St Luke’s Church is a Grade II* Listed Building in a prominent location in the Duke Street Conservation Area. Constructed in 1829, it was badly bomb-damaged during World War II.
2. It was acquired by the City Council in 1968 and has been maintained as a ‘managed ruin’ within a public garden that includes memorials to the Irish Famine and Roy Castle. The church and gardens are maintained at a cost of £15,000 per annum.
3. The former church is included as one of 13 entries for Liverpool on English Heritage’s national Buildings at Risk Register 2003 (for grade I and II* listings). It is a City Council objective to reduce this number.
Previous Study of the Site
4. A steering group, set up to consider St Luke’s future, first met on 11 April 2000. Its remit was to consider long-term maintenance, identify potential funding sources and consider options for use.
5. The formation of the steering group coincided with an approach from the Liverpool branch of the United Nations Association, represented by Mr and [name removed]. They were keen to explore the use of the church as a Peace Education Centre to support UNESCO’s International Year for the Culture of Peace and a Feasibility Study into this use was produced in November 2000. 6. The study investigated the construction of a free-standing building within the shell of the church at a cost of £4.2m. No reliable source of capital funds was identified to implement the proposal. Although a Business Plan was included in the Feasibility Study, it assumed public funding of running costs and failed to demonstrate the long-term financial viability of the Peace Education Centre. No further meaningful progress was made on this proposal.
Current Study of the Site
7. A further study was commissioned in 2003 by Liverpool Vision (see background papers) to investigate broader, alternative scenarios for the use of St. Luke’s Church and to prepare an options appraisal (complete with budget costs). The study, carried out by BDP and Amion, was produced in November 2003. It considered the following options for the building:
Option 1 - retaining the building as a controlled ruin with repair and minor upgrading to allow for occasional, event use (which it is anticipated would be self-funded). Estimated cost £692,000;
Options 2/3 - creating a large flexible-use conference centre/events space. Estimated cost up to £3,393,200;
Options 4/5 - creating an intensive and multi-use facility on two or three floors. Estimated cost up to £3,470,000 (this is similar to the earlier Peace Centre proposal);
Option 6 - landscaping of the gardens as an item be added to each of the above options. Estimated additional cost up to £280,900.
Conclusions of the Current Study
8. The study foresees limited market potential for redeveloping the building as an events or conference venue and states that it is difficult to see how a viable business plan for the multi-use option could be compiled. The study does not envisage the possibility of any private capital funding for any of the options nor any clear public sector streams that would meet the shortfall of the multi-use option.
9. The market analysis has indicated that there would be uncertain demand for a conference venue and that it would be a risky option.
10. There is no demand for additional community/public/educational space in the city centre and such a use would not generate sufficient revenue support for on-going annual running costs.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.