Agreed that - (a) the Committee notes the action being taken to control and manage the work of the utility companies and welcomes the introduction of the new powers in the Roads and Streetworks Act, together with an agreed protocol between the utility companies and the City Council; (b) the recommendations contained within the report be approved so far as this Committee is concerned and referred to the Overview and Scrutiny Select Committee; and (c) because of the necessity to continue to monitor the CCMS the panel be retained with its current membership for the remainder of the Municipal ... view the full minutes text for item 217.
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
Report to Regeneration and Economic Development Select Committee
Liverpool City Council
Report to: Regeneration and Economic Development Select Committee
Subject: Final Report of the City Centre Movement Scrutiny Panel
Report no: EDR/13/08
Date: 6 February 2008
Reporting officer: Mike Burchnall, AED Regeneration Services
Contact officer: Christine Wray 233 8146
Ward: Central and parts of Riverside and Princes Park
1. Purpose and recommendations
Introduction
The Scrutiny Panel was established in June 2007 with the following terms of reference -
To examine the City Centre Movement Strategy; to analyse its effectiveness against originally stated objectives and current conditions; review and make recommendations in relation to further analysis that has been carried out recently; and to review and provide recommendations to the Executive Member and Executive Board on the programme of further work being developed post 2008.
The Panel was chaired by Councillor Stuart Monkcom and comprised -
Councillors John Coyne, Dave Hanratty, Ian Jobling, Roger Johnston, Janet Kent, the Chair of the Select Committee, Councillor Eddie Clein and Executive Member, Councillor Mike Storey.
The Panel has met on 8 occasions and received presentation from and/or interviewed a range of witnesses as follows –
Liverpool Chamber of Commence Steve Pearse Liverpool Vision Ian McCarthy Business Liverpool Andy Green Liverpool City Council: Executive Members Peter Millea and Mike Storey AED Regeneration Mike Burchnall City Centre Management Team Mike Coburn Planning Service Nigel Lee and Rob Burns Highways Manager Steve Holcroft Highways Projects Christine Wray Merseyside Police Angela Smith, Graham Ward Steve Hardy Merseytravel Steve Cook Arriva, Martin Taylor 2020 Liverpool Dave Smallwood A resident in the City Centre, Maureen Delij Independent Consultant Professor Peter Bonsall JMP Consulting Phil Sapiro
All Panel meetings were open to the public and the minutes of each meeting can be viewed on the internet.
KEY RECOMMENDATIONS
Certain issues recurred throughout the Panel’s proceedings leading members to make recommendations in three key areas.
Understanding CCMS
Publicity for individual schemes has been successful but a stronger publicity and communication strategy is required to ensure improved support for CCMS by explaining what it is, what it is seeking to deliver and how it sets out to achieve it.
Enforcement
Enforcement of Traffic Regulation Orders in general must be more robustly implemented and, in particular, Camera enforcement of bus lanes should be introduced as quickly as possible. Unambiguous signage is key to this requirement.
Work by the Utilities
A further key issue that was frequently raised before the Panel or by Panel members was the effect of work by contractors acting for the Utilities in respect of the disruption they cause to traffic and the often poor standard of reinstatement of their works. The Panel was especially concerned and sometimes appalled at the state of recently completed high grade surfacing materials when affected by utilities’ works.
Members shared a sense of frustration that, whilst they would have wished to make explicit recommendations, they were aware that this is a concern of long standing and it was difficult to bring anything new to it. Nevertheless:
The Panel endorsed efforts made locally, for example through the Network Management Approvals Team and nationally, by the DfT, to seek improvement in the synergy of the Utilities working with others to reduce the disruption of roadworks and to obviate the visual impact of their works on the public realm.
In particular the Panel was pleased to hear of a voluntary Code of Practice that is in preparation by the City Council working with the Utilities. This will cover both coordination and quality of the works and will, amongst other matters, seek to reduce the time period between the temporary and permanent reinstatement of works. This approach was commended.
Other recommendations
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.