Confirmation of an immediate Article 4 Direction for Houses in Multiple Occupation in 13 wards (HMO) following public consultation
NotedExecutive2 papers
AI summaryMerton Cabinet recommends making borough-wide HMO planning controls permanent in 13 wards from 24 March 2026, with full Council vote due 16 September 2026.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeNotedCabinet asks Council to make the HMO rule permanent
MoneyPossible compensation £30,000-£250,000 per propertyNo budget identified for compensation or officer work
What happens nextFull Council vote 16 September 2026Statutory deadline to confirm is 23 September 2026
Who it affectsHMO landlords and residents in 13 wardsPlanning permission now required for all new small HMOs
What was decided
Cabinet recommends to full Council that the immediate Article 4 Direction for small HMOs in 13 wards, which started on 24th March 2026, be confirmed to make it permanent. Report P5, P9, 3.1
Cabinet notes that there is an entitlement to compensation for the first 12 months where planning permission is refused for development that would have been permitted development but for the Article 4 Direction. Report P6, P10
Why
Public consultation between Friday 8th May and Friday 19th June 2026 received 50 representations, with 82% supporting the Direction and a petition of 35 signatures also in support. Report 4.12, 4.13
Merton's Development and Planning Applications Committee unanimously recommended confirmation at its meeting on 18th June 2026. Report P15
Officers cite concerns about cumulative impact of HMOs on amenity, including noise, waste, parking and anti-social behaviour, and the need to protect family housing and vulnerable tenants. Report 4.15, 4.16, 4.21, P18, P19
What happens next
Full Council is scheduled to consider confirmation on Wednesday 16 September 2026, ahead of the statutory deadline of 23 September 2026. Report P63, P64, 4.6
If confirmed, the Direction will continue in force beyond six months; the council remains liable to pay compensation on refused applications made within the first 12 months, that is until 23 March 2027. Report 4.5, P71
The money
£30,000-£250,000 Potential compensation per property reported to full Council on 18 April 2023
Options considered
Chosen: Confirm the immediate Article 4 Direction to make it permanent. Strong public support, DPAC unanimous recommendation, and evidence of HMO impacts on amenity Report 4.12, 4.13
Rejected: Introduce a non-immediate Article 4 Direction instead to avoid compensation liability. Would take longer to take effect; an immediate Direction was chosen on 19th February 2026 Report 3.2, 4.2
Implications
Legal: Robust evidence is needed to support both the Article 4 Direction and Landlord Licensing in the smallest, clearly defined geographical areas to avoid legal challenge. Report P69, P70, P71
Financial: Revenue costs for Article 4 production are met within existing revenue budgets on cost code 401083; additional funds would need to be identified for any successful compensation claims. Report P72
Equalities: The council will need to consider its Public Sector Equality Duty under the Equality Act 2010 throughout this process. Report P73
Climate: The decision has a positive impact on Merton's Climate Strategy and Action Plan, as the 2024 Local Plan introduces carbon reduction requirements for small development sites. Report P74
Risk: The Secretary of State has the power to modify or cancel the Article 4 Direction at any time before or after it is confirmed. Report 4.11, P71
Who and where
HMO landlords operating in the 13 wards Report P3, 4.3
Residents of the 13 wards: Abbey, Cannon Hill, Hillside, Lower Morden, Merton Park, Ravensbury, Raynes Park, St Helier, Wandle, West Barnes, Wimbledon Park, Wimbledon Town and Dundonald, and Village Report 4.3
Prospective HMO tenants and applicants for HMO planning permission across the borough Report 3.2, 4.4
Timeline
19th February 2026: Cabinet resolved to introduce the immediate Article 4 Direction for 13 wards Report 4.2, 3.2
24th March 2026: Immediate Article 4 Direction took effect; planning permission required for all new small HMOs in Merton Report 3.2, 4.4, 4.6
26th May 2026: Secretary of State acknowledged notification and indicated no objection to the process Report 4.11, P37
18th June 2026: Development and Planning Applications Committee unanimously recommended confirmation Report P15, P63
Friday 8th May - Friday 19th June 2026: Public consultation on confirming the Direction Report 3.3
13th July 2026: Cabinet meeting to recommend confirmation to full Council Report P2
Wednesday 16 September 2026: Full Council meeting scheduled to confirm the Direction Report P63
23rd September 2026: Statutory six-month deadline for confirming the Direction Report P64, 4.6
23 March 2027: End of 12-month period during which compensation may be payable on refused HMO applications
Plain English for the jargon
Article 4 Direction: A planning power that withdraws permitted development rights, so that specified development (here, small HMOs) requires a planning application.
HMO (House in Multiple Occupation): A residential property occupied by three or more tenants from more than one household, as defined by housing law.
Immediate Article 4 Direction: An Article 4 Direction that takes effect straight away on being made, which makes the council liable to pay compensation for refused applications in the first 12 months.
Permitted development: Building or change of use that can be carried out without a full planning application, subject to conditions.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item5
Resolved
Cabinet is asked: A. That, following review of the consultation responses, Cabinet recommends to Council that the immediate Article 4 Direction for small HMOs covering the 13 wards listed in the report, which started on 24th March 2026, be Confirmed to make it permanent. B. To note that there is an entitlement to compensation for the first 12 months where planning permission is refused for development that would have been permitted development but for an Article 4 Direction as set out in the report. Cabinet is asked: A. That, following review of the consultation responses, Cabinet recommends to Council that the immediate Article 4 Direction for small HMOs covering the 13 wards listed in the report, which started on 24th March 2026, be Confirmed to make it permanent. B. To note that there is an entitlement to compensation for the first 12 months where planning permission is refused for development that would have been permitted development but for an Article 4 Direction as set out in the report.
Word for word from the decision Merton published for this meeting.Source: democracy.merton.gov.uk
Report cover sheet NAME OF DECISION-MAKER DATE Cabinet 13th July 2026
REPORT/DECISION TITLE WARD(S) Abbey, Cannon Hill, Confirmation of an immediate Article 4 Hillside, Lower Morden, Merton Park, Raynes Park, Ravensbury, St Helier, Direction for Houses in Multiple Occupation Village, West Barnes, Wimbledon in 13 wards (HMO) following public Park, Wandle and, Wimbledon Town consultation. and Dundonald. (Current Article 4 Direction introduced in 2022 covers - Colliers Wood, Cricket Green, Figge’s Marsh, Graveney, Lavender Fields, Longthornton and Pollards Hill wards). CHIEF OFFICER(S) CABINET/LEAD MEMBER(S) Jeremy Smalley, Executive Director of Name: Cllr Andrew Judge, Cabinet Housing and Sustainable Development Member for Housing and Sustainable Development
DECISION CLASSIFICATION IS THE FINAL DECISION ON THE Key RECOMMENDATIONS IN THIS REPORT TO BE MADE AT THIS Is the decision exempt from call in? MEETING? No Is the report, in whole or in part, exempt No from publication? No
Page 33 1. Recommendations Cabinet is asked: A. That, following review of the consultation responses, Cabinet recommends to Council that the immediate Article 4 Direction for small HMOs covering the 13 wards listed in the report, which started on 24th March 2026, be Confirmed to make it permanent.
B. To note that there is an entitlement to compensation for the first 12 months where planning permission is refused for development that would have been permitted development but for an Article 4 Direction as set out in the report.
Page 34 Recommendations, report summary and relevance to strategic priorities
2. Recommendations (repeated from page 1) Cabinet is asked:
A. That, following review of the consultation responses, Cabinet recommends to Council that the immediate Article 4 Direction for small HMOs covering the 13 wards listed in the report, which started on 24th March 2026, be Confirmed to make it permanent.
B. To note that there is an entitlement to compensation for the first 12 months where planning permission is refused for development that would have been permitted development but for an Article 4 Direction as set out in the report.
3. Executive summary Houses of Multiple Occupation (HMOs)
3.1This report is to seek Cabinet's recommendation to advise full council to confirm (i.e. making permanent) the Article 4 direction for small HMOs for 13 wards in Merton, having considered the feedback from public consultation and the Development and Planning Applications Committee.
3.2On 16th February 2026 Cabinet resolved to introduce an immediate Article 4 Direction for small HMOs in 13 wards, giving effect to a borough-wide approach as the same rule was introduced in 2022 for the other seven wards. It started on 24th March 2026. From that day planning permission is required for all new HMOs in Merton.
3.3This report sets out that to continue the Article 4 Direction permanently (i.e. beyond six months) the council must carry out a public consultation and resolve to “confirm” the Direction before 23 September 2026. Public consultation took place between Friday 8th May - Friday 19 June 2026. The report was considered by the Development and Planning Applications
Page 35 Committee – 18 June 2026 in their advisory function; DPAC unanimously recommended to Cabinet and Council to confirm the immediate Article 4 Direction on HMOs.
Relevance to strategic priorities, including Council Plan priorities Strategic priority Relevant? Brief explanation of relevance
Borough of Sport
Building a HMOs: sustainable future Many landlords provide a good standard of accommodation and service to their tenants, however there are some who do not. Given the demand for housing, unscrupulous landlords take advantage of those who have least choice in the market due to their personal x circumstances and offer substandard and poorly managed accommodation, particularly in HMOs. This report will support the council in improving standards in the private sector for tenants and their neighbours.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Morden Town Centre RegenerationCabinet is asked to: A. Note the progress made on the Programme since Cabinet approved the procurement of a developme...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.