CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Worcester City Council
Cabinet, Tuesday 11 June 2013 at 7.00pm

Worcester Swimming Pool Procurement - Design Team Contract Award - Key Decision

Agreed Executive 2 papers

Cabinet agreed this item on Tuesday 11 June 2013. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item17

Resolved

- That under Section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972, the press and public be excluded from the meeting for the following items of business on the grounds that they involve the likely disclosure of information as defined in Schedule 12A of the said Act. The Cabinet considered the report and agreed the recommendations as set out in the report.
Word for word from the decision Worcester published for this meeting. Source: committee.worcester.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Worcester's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet, 1 pages

Appendix 2 Worcester City Council

Appointment of Project Management and Design Consultants - Evaluation Criteria and Scoring Post Clarification Meetings with Price Scoring based on Design Team Contracted Cost (i.e. Less costs to be novated to Contractor)

Number of Submissions received 3

Project Evaluation Weighting Quality % Price % 60 40

Minimum Quality threshold (per criterion) % 25

Minimum Quality threshold (whole section) % 50

Quality Section 1 2 3 Deloitte Turner Townsend Lend Lease Consulting (EMEA) Ltd Pre-weighted Weighted Pre- Pre-weighted Weighted Pre-weighted Weighted Weighted Section Description Score Weighting Score PASS/FAIL PASS/FAIL PASS/FAIL weighted Score Score Score Score Score Available Available Score S2.1 Experience & Expertise 5 5 25 PASS 5 25.00 PASS 4 20.00 PASS 4 20.00 S2.2 a Structure 5 0.5 2.5 PASS 4 2.00 PASS 4 2.00 PASS 4 2.00 S2.2 b Main Contact 5 1 5 PASS 5 5.00 PASS 4 4.00 PASS 3 3.00 S2.2 c Team Members 5 2.5 12.5 PASS 5 12.50 PASS 4 10.00 PASS 4 10.00 S2.3 Key Assumptions 5 1 5 PASS 4 4.00 PASS 3 3.00 PASS 4 4.00 S2.4 a Project Execution Plan 5 4 20 PASS 3 12.00 PASS 4 16.00 PASS 3 12.00 S2.4 b Managing Affordability 5 1 5 PASS 5 5.00 PASS 5 5.00 PASS 4 4.00 S2.4 c Design Stage 5 2 10 PASS 5 10.00 PASS 4 8.00 PASS 4 8.00 S2.4 d Procurement & Management of Main Contractor 5 2 10 PASS 4 8.00 PASS 5 10.00 PASS 4 8.00 S2.4 e Innovation 5 1 5 PASS 4 4.00 PASS 4 4.00 PASS 4 4.00 100 Raw Quality Score 87.50 Raw Quality Score 82.00 Raw Quality Score 75.00 Average Quality Scored (Value) 81.50 Average Quality Scored(Points) 92.64

1 point to be added for every 1% below average % Above/below average 7.36 % Above/below average 0.61 % Above/below average -7.98 1 point to be deducted for every 1% above average Points added/deducted 7.36 Points added/deducted 0.61 Points added/deducted -7.98

Quality Section Score 100.00 Quality Section Score 93.25 Quality Section Score 84.66 Quality Section Rank 1 Quality Section Rank 2 Quality Section Rank 3

Price Section

Average Price Tendered (Value) 474,769 Tender Price £508,022 Tender Price £431,799 Tender Price £484,485 Average Price Tendered (Points) 90.95

1 point to be added for every 1% below average % Above/below average 7.00 % Above/below average -9.05 % Above/below average 2.05 1 point to be deducted for every 1% above average Points added/deducted -7.00 Points added/deducted 9.05 Points added/deducted -2.05

Price Section Score 83.95 Price Section Score 100.00 Price Section Score 88.90 Price Section Rank 3 Price Section Rank 1 Price Section Rank 2

Overall Score Section

Project Quality Weighting x Quality Section Score 60% 60.00 60% 55.95 60% 50.80 Project Price Weighting x Price Section Score 40% 33.58 40% 40.00 40% 35.56

Overall Score 93.58 Overall Score 95.95 Overall Score 86.36 Overall Rank 2 Overall Rank 1 Overall Rank 3

Without Quality Weighting Applied 60% 52.50 49.20 45.00 Price 40% 33.58 40.00 35.56

Overall Score 86.08 Overall Score 89.20 Overall Score 80.56 Overall Rank 2 Overall Rank 1 Overall Rank 3

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Design Team Moderated Evaluation SheetReport 1 pages DownloadRead as text
PDF
Worcester Swimming Pool Procurement: Design Team Contract Award: Key DecisionDecisions 6 pages Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

On this subject at Worcester

Search all
  1. Worcester Swimming Pool Procurement - Design Team Contract Award - Key DecisionThis decision
  2. Worcester Citizens Swimming Bath Association - Funding Request for Capital Works at Lower Wick Swimming PoolAgreed
  3. Prior Approval Consent - PRA 18A02 - Former Worcester Swimming Pool and Fitness Centre Site, Sansome WalkApproved
  4. Provision of New Swimming Pool for Worcester Project Progress ReportDecided
  5. Leisure Connection Contract Extension - Perdiswell Sports Centre, Perdiswell Golf Course and Worcester Swimming Pool - Key DecisionAgreed
  6. Worcester Swimming Pool Contractor Procurement - Key DecisionAgreed

More from Worcester Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
21 Mar 2017 MinutesThat the minutes of the meeting held on 14 th February 2017 be approved as a correct record and signed by the Chairman. Approved Open
21 Mar 2017 The Shambles Public Realm Improvement - Key DecisionThat the Cabinet agree to approve expenditure of £400,000 from the 2015-16 New Homes Bonus Allocation for public real... Agreed Open
21 Mar 2017 Worcester City Masterplan UpdateThat the Cabinet agree to: 1. approve the allocation £75k from the “City Plan Fund” towards the production of an upda... Agreed Open
21 Mar 2017 Perdiswell Golf CourseThat the Cabinet agree to: 1. endorse the proposals in this report, in particular the maintenance of ‘pay and play’ p... Agreed Open
21 Mar 2017 Refurbishment of the Cinderella Sports Ground - Key DecisionThat the Cabinet agree to: 1. approve the project to refurbish the Cinderella Sports Ground as a Community sports fac... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies