That the application be approved subject to the conditions and informatives listed in the report. Reasons: i. The use and scale of the proposed building is such that it is inappropriate development in the Green Belt. It would have a moderately harmful impact on the visual character and amenity of the landscape. Green Belt policy states that the application should be refused unless any harm resulting from the proposal is clearly outweighed by other considerations. ii. In assessing whether very special circumstances exist, significant regard is given to the fact that the site is an established water treatment plant which supplies around a third of Yorkshire Water’s drinking water. The site is located wholly in the Green Belt. The proposed building cannot be located outside the Green Belt. The applicant states that the building is essential in respect to improvements to ensure a sustainable, resilient water supply, essential for public health and to assist in facilitating growth within the York area and in the works’ wider supply area. Although the structure is tall it is not considered unduly intrusive. Its scale has been reduced from the original submission and its height reflects that of the existing silos on the site. It is considered that the particular circumstances relating to the pressing need for the building and the inability to re-locate it outside the Green Belt does amount to very special circumstances which would clearly outweigh the harm to the Green Belt and local landscape.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
Date: 15 November 2018 Ward: Wheldrake Team: Major and Parish: Elvington Parish Council Commercial Team
Reference: 18/01786/FUL Application at: Elvington Water Treatment Works Kexby Lane Elvington York For: Erection of plant building used for the preparation of calcium hydroxide. By: Yorkshire Water Services Application Type: Full Application Target Date: 10 October 2018 Recommendation: Approve
1.0PROPOSAL
1.1The application site is Elvington Water Treatment Works located north-east of Elvington village. It contains a mixture of functional buildings, hard standing, grassed areas and water storage. It is located next to the River Derwent for the purposes of river abstraction for raw water. The entrance to the site is accessed from Daubey Lane close to the entrance to the village primary school. The nearest house is around 360 metres from the fenced enclosure of the site. There is also landscaped buffer land outside the fence that is within the ownership of the applicant.
1.2It is proposed to erect a building to contain new apparatus related to the preparation of calcium hydroxide. The chemical is used in the process of the treatment of drinking water. The building is proposed on grass scrubland at the south western part of the enclosed area. It is of a functional design with a tower sitting on a larger base. The tower part of the structure is proposed to be 20 metres tall. It would be located around 440m from the nearest home. The tower was initially proposed to be 28 metres high, however, revisions have been received reducing the scale. The existing silos that serve a similar role and will become redundant if the new development takes place are not proposed to be removed in the foreseeable future.
RELEVANT HISTORY
1.3There have been a number of planning permissions over the past 20 years for plant and buildings related to the treatment of water on site.
1.4In 2008 (07/02915/FUL) planning permission was granted for the erection of a 50m high environmental monitoring mast and associated guy ropes for a temporary period of 18 months.
Application Reference Number: 18/01786/FUL Item No: 4f 1.5 In 2015 (15/02639/FULM) planning permission was granted for the Installation of a solar photovoltaic array with associated infrastructure including kiosks, security fencing, CCTV and internal access track on land within the ownership of the site but outside the fenced enclosure of the works. This has not been implemented to date. The permission expires in April 2019.
2.0POLICY CONTEXT
2.1National Planning Policy Framework (2018)
2.2Publication Draft Local Plan (2018)
Policy SS2 The Role of York's Green Belt. Policy GB1 Development in the Green Belt Policy D1 Placemaking Policy D2 Landscape and Setting
2.3City of York Draft Local Plan (2005)
Policy GB1 Development in the Green Belt.
3.0CONSULTATIONS
INTERNAL
Public Protection
3.1Have considered the application in terms of environmental impacts such as noise and dust and raise no objections and recommend no conditions to permission.
Flood Risk Manager
3.2No objections subject to surface water run off details being considered.
Design, Conservation and Sustainable Development (Ecology and Countryside Officer)
3.3No objections.
EXTERNAL
Parish Council 3.4 The following comments were received in respect to the revised scheme for a 20 m high building: We have no objections - but would wish to have a condition imposed which maximises the additional screening measures to the southern boundary, as offered by Yorkshire Water. Application Reference Number: 18/01786/FUL Item No: 4f Civil Aviation Authority
3.5No comments received.
Natural England
3.6No comments received.
Neighbours and Publicity
3.7One objection was received stating that a 28m high building would be an eyesore in the Green Belt and too close to the village of Elvington.
4.0APPRAISAL
4.1Key Issues
Acceptability within the Green Belt Visual Impact Highways Impact on wildlife and ecology Flood risk
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.