REFUSED The NPPF (paragraph 193) states that great weight should be given to a heritage asset’s conservation, with greater weight being given to assets of higher importance. Any harm to, or loss of, the significance a designated heritage asset requires clear and convincing justification (paragraph 194), and where there would be less than substantial harm to the significance of the significance of a designated heritage asset, this harm should be weighed against the public benefits of the proposal (paragraph 196). The proximity of the proposed replacement dwelling to the Scheduled Ancient Monument (Berkhamsted Castle) would, as a result of its bulk, mass and scale, cause less than substantial harm to the setting of the heritage asset which is of the highest level of significance. Whilst there would be personal benefits accruing to the applicant, there are no obvious public benefits; nor have any been advanced as part of the application. The proposed development would also fail protect or enhance a significant view within a character area. The application is therefore contrary the NPPF (paragraph 196) and Policy CS27 of the Dacorum Core Strategy (2013), which states that the integrity, setting and distinctiveness of designated heritage assets will be protected, conserved and if appropriate enhanced. The proposal is also contrary to Policy CS11 (d) of the Dacorum Core Strategy (2013). Note: The Chair moved to consider Item 5d as the next item for discussion, followed by 5c and then returning to the correct running order. These minutes have maintained numeric order for ease of reference.
Word for word from the decision Dacorum published for this meeting.Source: democracy.dacorum.gov.uk
2.1The principle of a replacement dwelling is acceptable in this area in accordance with Policy CS4 of the Dacorum Core Strategy.
2.2In terms of heritage impacts, the proposed design is suitable and would not be harmful to significance of the nearby Scheduled Ancient Monument or the setting of the Berkhamsted Conservation Area, thereby complying with Policy CS27 of the Dacorum Core Strategy.
2.3The design respects the rhythm of the street and would satisfactorily integrate with the streetscape character, in accordance with Policies CS11 and CS12 of the Dacorum Core Strategy.
3. SITE DESCRIPTION
3.1The application site comprises of a two-storey, detached dwellinghouse and associated curtilage, which occupies a large plot on the westernmost side of Brownlow Road, Berkhamsted.
4. PROPOSAL
4.1Planning permission is sought for the demolition of the existing dwelling and the construction of a replacement dwelling.
5. PLANNING HISTORY
Planning Applications (If Any):
Appeals (If Any):
6. CONSTRAINTS
Area of Archaeological Significance: 21 CIL Zone: CIL1 Conservation Area: BERKHAMSTED Former Land Use (Risk Zone): Parish: Berkhamsted CP RAF Halton and Chenies Zone: RAF HALTON: DOTTED BLACK ZONE RAF Halton and Chenies Zone: Yellow (45.7m) Railway (100m Buffer): Railway: 100m buffer Residential Area (Town/Village): Residential Area in Town Village (Berkhamsted) Residential Character Area: BCA13 Parking Standard: New Zone 3 EA Source Protection Zone: 3 EA Source Protection Zone: 2 Town: Berkhamsted
7. REPRESENTATIONS
Consultation responses
7.1These are reproduced in full at Appendix A.
Neighbour notification/site notice responses
7.2These are reproduced in full at Appendix B.
8. PLANNING POLICIES
Main Documents:
National Planning Policy Framework (February 2019) Dacorum Core Strategy 2006-2031 (adopted September 2013) Dacorum Borough Local Plan 1999-2011 (adopted April 2004)
Relevant Policies:
Dacorum Borough Council Core Strategy (2013) NP1 - Supporting Development CS1 - Distribution of Development CS4 - The Towns and Large Villages CS8 - Sustainable Transport CS10 - Quality of Settlement Design CS11 - Quality of Neighbourhood Design CS12 - Quality of Site Design CS27 - Quality of the Historic Environment CS29 - Sustainable Design and Construction CS31 – Water Management CS32 - Air, Soil and Water Quality CS35 - Infrastructure and Developer Contributions
Dacorum Borough Local Plan (2004) Policy 10 - Optimising the Use of Urban Land Policy 12 - Infrastructure Provision and Phasing Policy 13 - Planning Conditions and Planning Obligations Policy 15 - Retention of Housing Policy 18 - The Size of New Dwellings Policy 51 - Development and Transport Impacts Policy 100 - Tree and Woodland Planting Policy 118 - Important Archaeological Remains Policy 120 - Development in Conservation Areas
Saved Appendix 3 - Layout and Design of Residential Areas
Supplementary Planning Guidance/Documents Roads in Hertfordshire, Highway Design Guide 3rd Edition (2011) Site Layout and Planning for Daylight and Sunlight: A Guide to Good Practice (2011) Parking Standards Supplementary Planning Document (2020)
9. CONSIDERATIONS
Main Issues
9.1The main issues to consider are:
Principle of the development; Impact on Significance of Heritage Assets Quality of Design / Impact on Visual Amenity Impact on Amenity of Neighbours Highway Safety and Parking Provision
Principle of the Development
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
5b20/01429/FUL Demolition of existing detached house, to be replaced with a new detached home.-Mabuhay, Brownlow Road, Berkhamsted, HertfordshireThis decision
20/01429/FUL Demolition of existing detached house, to be replaced with a new detached home.-Mabuhay, Brownlow Road, Berkhamsted, HertfordshireThis decision
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.