AI summaryArgyll and Bute EDI Committee approves keeping charges at four well used public toilets and reverting five others to free entry with honesty boxes, holding over around £150,000 of unspent funding.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeNotedCharges kept at four sites, five revert to free
Moneyc. £150k unspent held overFrom original £300,000 programme
What happens nextFurther report on PC estateUsing held over funding, in 2026/27
Who it affectsUsers of 9 PC sitesPlus wider Argyll and Bute public
What was decided
The Committee approved retaining door access charging at four higher performing sites: Inveraray, Helensburgh, Ardrishaig and Lochgilphead, on the basis that income and operational performance are acceptable there. Report P9
The Committee agreed to recommend to the full Council that the remaining five sites revert to free access supported by honesty boxes, as a proportionate, low cost contribution mechanism. Report P9
The Committee agreed that the remaining unspent funding from the original £300,000 programme, around £150,000, be held over for a further report on future options for the Public Convenience estate. Report P9, 5.1
Why
The four retained sites generate the majority of income and operate relatively well, while the other five sites have reliability issues and negligible returns from low usage. Report 2.3, 5.1, 5.5
Officers found the door access system has not delivered the intended return on investment, with frequent faults, vandalism and a high administrative burden that outweighs income at low volume rural sites. Report 5.5
Public conveniences are a non statutory service, and the proposed hybrid model is presented as a proportionate, operationally manageable way to retain some income while keeping facilities open. Report 2.1, 2.2
What happens next
A further report is to be brought forward on options for the Public Convenience estate, including improvements to retained charging sites, using the held over funding. Report 5.1, P9
The service will review existing arrangements and report back in 2026/27, in line with the Council budget decision of 25 February 2026 not to close public conveniences. Report 6.1
Officers will investigate alternative provision, including community asset transfer and co production, and convert existing coin boxes to honesty boxes at the five sites proposed for free access.
The money
£0.010m Savings proposed in financial year 2018/19 from closing 30 PCs Report P2
£0.024m Savings proposed in financial year 2019/20 from closing 30 PCs Report P2
£0.024m Savings proposed in financial year 2020/21 from closing 30 PCs Report P2
£0.1m Budget established in 2020 Council budget for charging project
£200,000 Additional Crown Estate funding approved in 2022/23
£300,000 Total programme budget for door access rollout Report 5.1
£0.132m Spent to date on hardware, installation, ICT and project management Report 5.1
c. £150k Remaining unspent funding to be held over for further report Report P9
£0.331m Net annual cost to the Council of operating 57 PCs Report 2.2
just over £67,000 Income from public conveniences in a full financial year Report 2.2
£67,357 Total PC income in 2024/25 across the nine charging sites and Oban
Options considered
Chosen: Retain charging at four higher performing sites and revert five others to free access with honesty boxes. Four sites generate over 90% of income; other five have reliability issues, low usage and disproportionate maintenance cost Report 2.3, P9
Rejected: Continue full rollout of door access charging across the wider estate. Reviews found charging is not viable at rural and low volume sites, with administrative and maintenance burden outweighing income Report 5.5
Rejected: Close public conveniences to save money. Council decided in February 2018 and again on 25 February 2026 not to close PCs, instead reviewing arrangements Report 1.1, 2.2, 6.1
Implications
Financial: Officers do not expect the change to have any significant financial disbenefit; £0.132m of the £0.300m programme has been spent so far. Report 5.1
Legal: No known legal implications identified.
Staffing: No known HR implications identified.
Other: Policy implication: this would be a variation to the current position on charging for access to PCs, reducing the number of sites that charge. Report 8.1
Risk: Financial risk noted; the proposed approach is described as a more proportionate and sustainable model.
Other: One implication is identified for Island Communities.
Other: Customer service implication: signage and simplified messaging will be developed at sites moving to honesty boxes.
Equalities: No known Fairer Scotland Duty, equalities or Children's Rights and Wellbeing implications identified.
Who and where
Users of public conveniences at the four retained charging sites in Inveraray, Helensburgh, Ardrishaig and Lochgilphead Report P9, 2.3
Users of the other five sites that will move to free access with honesty boxes, including Glenmorag, Port Bannatyne, Colintraive, Tighnabruaich and Sandbank
Communities, visitors and tourists in Argyll and Bute who rely on the 57 public convenience sites Report 2.1
Council officers and contractors who have been managing faults, cash collection and maintenance at the charging sites
Timeline
February 2018: Council budget meeting: original proposal to close 30 public conveniences, not taken forward Report 1.1, 1.2
6 December 2018: EDI Committee agreed the principle of charging at 16 high footfall sites, honesty box trial at medium footfall sites, and one year community ownership promotion Report 1.3, P6
2020: Budget of £0.1m established for the charging project
2020 to 2021: Project paused due to COVID 19 impact on suppliers and Council resources
April 2022: Tender issued via Public Contracts Scotland; one compliant bid received above original allocation
2022/23: Members approved additional £200,000 Crown Estate funding, increasing total budget to £300,000
Late 2023 to spring 2024: Phase One installation of door access charging at nine sites
June 2024: EDI Committee agreed to pause the remainder of the programme pending review of system reliability and income Report 1.4
25 February 2026: Council budget meeting: agreed not to close public conveniences and to review arrangements, reporting back in 2026/27 Report 6.1
19 March 2026: EDI Committee approves hybrid model and recommendation on honesty boxes Report P9
Plain English for the jargon
EDI Committee: Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee of Argyll and Bute Council
Door access charging system: Electronic payment release doors supporting cash and contactless payment, used to charge for entry to public conveniences
Honesty box: An unattended collection box where users make a voluntary contribution
Phase One / Phase Two: Phased rollout of charging; Phase One covered nine sites, Phase Two was paused in June 2024
Crown Estate funding: Additional funding approved in 2022/23 to increase the charging project budget
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item9
Resolved
Decision The Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee: 1. noted the outcomes of the review of the door-access charging systems, undertaken following the Committee decision of June 2024 to pause the rollout pending assessment of system reliability and income performance; 2. approved the proposal to retain charging at the four higher-performing sites (Inveraray, Helensburgh, Ardrishaig and Lochgilphead), where income levels remain sustainable and operational performance is acceptable; 3. agreed to recommend to Council that the remaining five sites revert to free access supported by honesty boxes, on the basis that this provides a proportionate, low-cost means of maintaining a public contribution mechanism at locations where charging infrastructure is not commercially viable; 4. noted that public conveniences are a non-statutory service and that charging was introduced as a means of supporting financial sustainability. The proposed hybrid model ensures income continues to be generated in a way that is proportionate and operationally manageable; and 5. agreed that the remaining unspent funding from the original £300,000 programme (c. £150k) be held over for a further report setting out future options for the Public Convenience estate. (Reference: Report by Executive Director with responsibility for Roads and Infrastructure Services, dated 1 March 2026, submitted)
Word for word from the decision Argyll and Bute published for this meeting.Source: www.argyll-bute.gov.uk
Report to Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee
Executive summary
1.1The Council has been reviewing its public conveniences provision since the Council budget meeting in February 2018. The original proposal at this meeting was to close 30 public conveniences to realise the following savings –
a. £0.010m in financial year 2018/19 b. £0.024m in financial year 2019/20 c. £0.024m in financial year 2020/21
1.2This saving was not taken forward at this meeting, and it was agreed that the service would progress sustainable models including -
• turnstiles and franchising; • establishing a simpler asset transfer process; and • updating the EDI Committee on progress by the end of 2018.
1.3At its meeting on 6 December 2018, the Environment Development and Infrastructure (EDI) Committee agreed to -
a. the principle of charging at 16 high footfall facilities, b. the installation of honesty boxes at medium footfall facilities for a trial period of one year and reviewed after this, and c. promote, for a period of one year, the remainder of the facilities for community ownership.
1.4At its meeting in June 2024, the EDI committee was informed that 9 sites had introduced charging at the beginning of that year, and the committee agreed to defer the introduction of charging at the remaining high use sites until after summer 2024. 1.5 Since the introduction of charging via door-access payment systems, performance has varied significantly. Four sites—Inveraray, Helensburgh, Ardrishaig, and Lochgilphead—continue to generate the majority of income and operate relatively well. The remaining five sites have reliability issues, and negligible returns as a result of low usage.
1.6Further to the EDI Committee decision of June 2024 to pause rollout pending review, this report updates on financial and operational performance and outlines a proposed way.
RECOMMENDATIONS Members are asked to: a. Note the outcomes of the review of the door-access charging systems, undertaken following the EDI Committee decision of June 2024 to pause the rollout pending assessment of system reliability and income performance. b. Approve the proposal to retain charging at the four higher-performing sites (Inveraray, Helensburgh, Ardrishaig and Lochgilphead), where income levels remain sustainable and operational performance is acceptable. c. Approve the proposal that the remaining five sites revert to free access supported by honesty boxes, on the basis that this provides a proportionate, low-cost means of maintaining a public contribution mechanism at locations where charging infrastructure is not commercially viable. d. Note that public conveniences are a non-statutory service and that charging was introduced as a means of supporting financial sustainability. The proposed hybrid model ensures income continues to be generated in a way that is proportionate and operationally manageable. e. Agree that the remaining unspent funding from the original £300,000 programme (c. £150k) be held over for a further report setting out future options for the Public Convenience estate. ARGYLL AND BUTE COUNCIL ENVIRONMENT, DEVELOPMENT AND INFRASTRUCTURE COMMITTEE ROADS AND INFRASTRUCTURE 19 MARCH 2026
PUBLIC CONVENIENCE DOOR ACCESS CONTROL PROJECT
2.0INTRODUCTION
2.1Argyll and Bute Council operates 57 dedicated public conveniences across one of the largest and most rural local authority areas in Scotland. The facilities and services have consistently been highlighted by communities as an important and valued part of local infrastructure, particularly in areas that support tourism, long- distance travel, and ferry-based connectivity. However, they are not a statutory service.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Follow Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee at Argyll and Bute and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
Review of public convenience estateDecision The Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee – 1. noted the findings of the updated baseline re...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.