CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Argyll and Bute Council

AUDIT SCOTLAND REPORT: FLOODING IN COMMUNITIES (MOVING TOWARDS FLOOD RESILIENCE) - COUNCIL DUTIES AND IMPLICATIONS

Noted Committee 1 paper

AI summaryArgyll and Bute's environment committee backed calls for a clearer national flood funding model, saying the Audit Scotland report confirms the Oban scheme is stalled by external factors despite local readiness.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeNotedPushed for clearer national flood funding cycles
MoneyNo direct financial implicationsCouncil relies on 80% Scottish Government funding
What happens nextLobby COSLA and Scottish GovernmentDemand funding model clarity for Cycles 2 and 3
Who it affectsFlood risk management deliveryEspecially Oban Flood Protection Scheme

What was decided

The committee noted the national implications of flooding and flood resilience, including the duties and expectations placed on councils by Audit Scotland's 2025 report. Report 1.1

Members endorsed a proactive stance in national forums (COSLA and Scottish Government) to demand a funding model providing clarity on Cycle 2 and 3 allocations, and to prevent high-performing councils from being penalised by Cycle 1 cost overruns, particularly for the Oban scheme. Report P18

The committee acknowledged the success of the Campbeltown Flood Protection Scheme and the external strategic and financial risks stalling the proposed Oban scheme. Report P19, P28, P29

Why

Audit Scotland published its national report Flooding in Communities: Moving Towards Flood Resilience in August 2025, setting out statutory duties under the Flood Risk Management (Scotland) Act 2009 and wider expectations for councils. Report 1.1, 2.1, P22

The national funding model was described by Audit Scotland as 'not fit for purpose', with Cycle 1 scheme costs across Scotland rising from £350m to over £1bn, leaving no funding allocated to the Oban scheme despite local readiness. Report 4.4, P29, 4.5

The council's Flood Risk Management Team faces resource pressure, with shortages of specialist hydraulic modellers and engineers mirroring national findings, limiting capacity to scale up even if funding were released. Report 4.6

What happens next

The council will take a proactive stance in COSLA and Scottish Government forums to demand clarity on Cycle 2 and 3 funding allocations and protect high-performing councils from Cycle 1 cost overrun penalties. Report P18

The council will continue to align surface water management plans with Scottish Water's national investment cycles and seek integrated drainage solutions for schemes like Oban. Report P32

The Flood Risk Management Team will continue targeting support at vulnerable groups identified by Audit Scotland (older people, disabled people, low-income households, rural and island communities) to ensure equitable resilience outcomes. Report P35, P36, P37

The money

  • 80% national funding for major capital works Scottish Government contribution to flood schemes; Audit Scotland labels the model 'not fit for purpose' Report 4.5
  • 20% of major flood scheme costs Council contribution requirement for major flood schemes Report P24
  • from £350m to over £1bn Cost increase for Cycle 1 flood schemes across Scotland reported by Audit Scotland Report P29

Options considered

  • Chosen: Endorse a proactive national lobbying stance for clearer Cycle 2 and 3 funding allocations. To prevent high-performing councils being penalised and to enable the Oban scheme Report P18
  • Chosen: Note staffing and resource pressures mirroring Audit Scotland's national findings Report 4.6
  • Chosen: Acknowledge Campbeltown success and external risks stalling the Oban scheme Report P19, P28, P29

Implications

  • Financial: No direct financial implications from the report, but the 80% national funding model described as 'not fit for purpose' creates significant uncertainty for the council's capital programme. Report 4.5
  • Risk: Climate change impact on Argyll and Bute is a key corporate risk; stalled schemes like Oban pose reputational and physical risks from external funding bottlenecks beyond the council's control.
  • Equalities: Flooding disproportionately affects older people, disabled people, low-income households, people in poor-quality housing, rural and island communities, and digitally excluded residents. Report P35
  • Legal: The report reaffirms statutory duties under the Flood Risk Management (Scotland) Act 2009, including delivery against the Local Flood Risk Management Plan milestones. Report P22
  • Staffing: National findings highlight skills shortages in hydrology, modelling, drainage engineering and community resilience, constraining capacity even if funding were released. Report P24, 4.6
  • Climate: Flood resilience is identified as a key climate adaptation requirement, with the council holding 3,000 miles of coastline and high-rainfall catchments. Report 2.1

Who and where

  • Residents of Oban awaiting the stalled Oban Flood Protection Scheme Report P29, P32
  • Residents of Campbeltown protected by the delivered Campbeltown Flood Protection Scheme Report P28
  • Vulnerable groups disproportionately affected by flooding: older people, disabled people, low-income households, people in poor-quality housing, rural and island communities, and digitally excluded residents Report P35
  • Argyll and Bute Council's Flood Risk Management Team, facing specialist skills shortages Report 4.6

Timeline

  • 28 August 2025: Audit Scotland published its national report Flooding in Communities: Moving Towards Flood Resilience Report 1.1, 2.1
  • 2019: Flood Studies completed for the Oban scheme Report P29
  • 18 June 2026: Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee considered the report Report P7
  • Within 18 months of the report: Councils and Scottish Government expected to review flood service arrangements Report P24
  • 2024 to 2045: National Flood Resilience Strategy period, setting emerging strategic duties Report 2.3, P26

Plain English for the jargon

  • FRMA 2009: Flood Risk Management (Scotland) Act 2009, the primary statute setting council duties on flood risk
  • LFRMP: Local Flood Risk Management Plan, required under the FRMA 2009
  • SEPA: Scottish Environment Protection Agency, a national partner in flood risk management
  • COSLA: Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, the national body representing Scottish councils
  • Cycle 1, 2 and 3: Successive national funding cycles for flood protection schemes in Scotland
  • Nature-based solutions: Sustainable approaches prioritised by Audit Scotland for reducing flood risk
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item6

Resolved

Decision The Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee: 1. noted the national implications associated with flooding and flood resilience; 2. noted the duties and expectations placed on Councils by Audit Scotland’s 2025 report Flooding in Communities: Moving Towards Flood Resilience; 3. noted the staffing and resource pressures that mirror the national findings of Audit Scotland; 4. endorsed a proactive stance in national forums (COSLA / Scottish Government) to demand a funding model that provides clarity on Cycle 2 & 3 allocations and ensures that high-performing Councils are not penalised by national Cycle 1 cost overruns, in particular enabling the Oban Flood Protection Scheme; and 5. acknowledged the success of the Campbeltown delivery while noting the external strategic and financial risks stalling the proposed Oban scheme. (Reference: Report by Executive Director with Responsibility for Roads and Infrastructure, dated June 2026, submitted)
Word for word from the decision Argyll and Bute published for this meeting. Source: www.argyll-bute.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Argyll and Bute's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee

Executive summary

1.1This report provides Members with a summary of the duties, expectations and equality considerations for local authorities arising from Audit Scotland’s national report Flooding in Communities: Moving Towards Flood Resilience (published 28 August 2025). 1.2 The Audit Scotland report sets out clear statutory responsibilities for Councils under the Flood Risk Management (Scotland) Act 2009 (FRMA 2009), wider expectations relating to collaboration, community engagement and workforce capacity, and emerging duties under the National Flood Resilience Strategy (2024–2045). 1.3 The report also highlights significant inequalities in how flooding affects communities, with disproportionate impacts on older people, disabled people, low-income households, and rural and island communities. While the Council has demonstrated delivery excellence through the Campbeltown scheme, national systemic issues, including a funding model described by Audit Scotland as "not fit for purpose”, now present a critical risk to the progression of future works in Oban. Despite the Council having clear project objectives and technical readiness, the national funding landscape remains the primary barrier to progress. 1.4 There are no direct financial implications arising from this report, however, the national findings reinforce the need for sustained investment in flood risk management and resilience. The current bottleneck in national Cycle 1 funding poses a significant strategic risk to the Council's long-term financial planning for flood assets and our ability to meet the objectives set out in the Local Flood Risk Management Plan (LFRMP) as mandated by the FRMA 2009. 1.5 The Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee is asked to –

a) Consider the national implications associated with flooding and flood resilience;

b) Consider the duties and expectations placed on Councils by Audit Scotland’s 2025 report Flooding in Communities: Moving Towards Flood Resilience;

c) Note the staffing and resource pressures that mirror the national findings of Audit Scotland;

d) Endorse a proactive stance in national forums (COSLA / Scottish Government) to demand a funding model that provides clarity on Cycle 2 & 3 allocations and ensures that high-performing Councils are not penalised by national Cycle 1 cost overruns, in particular enabling the Oban Flood Protection Scheme; and

e) Acknowledge the success of the Campbeltown delivery while noting the external strategic and financial risks stalling the proposed Oban scheme. ARGYLL AND BUTE COUNCIL ENVIRONMENT, DEVELOPMENT AND INFRASTRUCTURE COMMITTEE

ROADS AND INFRASTRUCTURE 18TH JUNE 2026

AUDIT SCOTLAND REPORT: FLOODING IN COMMUNITIES (MOVING TOWARDS FLOOD RESILIENCE) - COUNCIL DUTIES AND IMPLICATIONS

2.0INTRODUCTION

2.1In August 2025, Audit Scotland published a definitive review of Scotland's flood preparedness. The report marks a paradigm shift from traditional "protection" (engineering) to "resilience" (adaptability). For a Council with 3,000 miles of coastline and high-rainfall catchments, the findings confirm that the status quo of national funding and support is unsustainable.

2.2The report assesses how well Scotland is planning for, funding and delivering flood resilience, and sets out expectations for Councils, SEPA, Scottish Water and the Scottish Government.

2.3This paper summaries the duties and responsibilities placed on Councils by the national report, including

a. statutory duties under the Flood Risk Management (Scotland) Act 2009, b. wider operational expectations, and c. emerging responsibilities under the National Flood Resilience Strategy (2024–2045).

2.4The paper also provides a concise summary of the equality, diversity and implications identified by Audit Scotland.

Recommendations

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
AUDIT SCOTLAND REPORT: FLOODING IN COMMUNITIES (MOVING TOWARDS FLOOD RESILIENCE): COUNCIL DUTIES AND IMPLICATIONSReport 223 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

13 of 20 attended
IP
Councillor Iain PatersonMember, apologies
JS
Julieann SmallSecretary, expected
KM
Katie McKenzieSecretary, expected
HM
Hazel MacInnesSecretary, expected
FM
Fiona McCallumSecretary, expected
JA
Councillor John ArmourChair, present
GH
Councillor Graham HardieMember, present
WH
Councillor Willie HumeMember, present
AK
Councillor Andrew KainMember, present
JL
Councillor Jim LynchMember, present
TM
Councillor Tommy MacPhersonMember, apologies
IM
Councillor Ian MacQuireMember, present

All 20 on the meeting page

On this subject at Argyll and Bute

Search all
  1. AUDIT SCOTLAND REPORT: FLOODING IN COMMUNITIES (MOVING TOWARDS FLOOD RESILIENCE) - COUNCIL DUTIES AND IMPLICATIONSThis decision
  2. Audit scotland publicationsNoted
  3. Audit scotland: publicationsNoted
  4. Audit Scotland Report - Financial Bulletin 2021/22Noted
  5. Audit Scotland Report - Digital Progress in Local GovernmentNoted
  6. Audit Scotland - 2020/21 Fraud and Irregularity ReportNoted

More from Argyll and Bute Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
9 Oct 2026 A816 bealach mor permanent solution updateDecision The Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee noted the following key points – 1. the £1.1m appr... Noted Open
9 Oct 2026 Review of public convenience estateDecision The Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee – 1. noted the findings of the updated baseline re... Noted Open
9 Oct 2026 Review of roads and infrastructure services updateDecision The Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee – 1. noted the progress to date on the RIS Review;... Noted Open
9 Oct 2026 Winter service policy 2026/27Decision The Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee – 1. approved the 2026/27 Winter Maintenance Polic... Approved Open
9 Oct 2026 Waste management updateDecision The Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee noted the content of the report. (Reference: Repor... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies