Resolved that - (i) the City Solicitor be instructed to serve a notice to quit on Cosmopolitan Housing Association terminating the leases on 40, 44, 46 and 50 Percy Street, 53-67 Upper Parliament Street and 1-9 Parliament Place and take all necessary steps to secure vacant possession; (ii) the Head of Property and Asset Management be requested to pursue a Dilapidations claim against Cosmopolitan Housing Association for the wants of repair arising out of their use and occupation of 40,44, 46 and 50 Percy Street, 53-67 Upper Parliament Street and 1-9 Parliament Place; (iii) the Head of Property and Asset Management be instructed to offer 40, 44, 46 and 50 Percy Street, 53-67 Upper Parliament Street and 1-9 Parliament Place for sale on the open market by way of competitive tender for owner occupation; and (iv) the results of the tender process and dilapidations negotiations be reported to the Executive Board for the final decisions on the disposal and dilapidations claim. RES/73
Word for word from the decision Liverpool published for this meeting.Source: councillors.liverpool.gov.uk
This report has been prepared to seek authority to obtain possession of 40, 44, 46 and 50 Percy Street, 53-67 Parliament Street and 1-9 Parliament Place, to pursue a dilapidations claim against Cosmopolitan Housing Association and offer the properties for sale on the open market by way of tender.
Background – Cosmopolitan leases
Cosmopolitan Housing Association hold the leases on two blocks of property in Canning on the terms shown in Appendix A. A total of 14 properties. All but the leases on 42 and 48 Percy Street expired in 2005.
The properties are currently converted into flats and have been used as student accommodation. 40-50 Percy Street and 53-57 Upper Parliament Street comprise 27 self-contained flats (14 one bed and 13 two bed) and 1-9 Parliament Place, 15 studio flats including kitchenette and private wc and wash hand basin.
Previous negotiations
As members are aware negotiations originally took place with Cosmopolitan with a view to renewing the leases. The purpose was to enable Cosmopolitan to re-invest and refurbish the properties with a view to the sale of flats in Percy Street and Parliament Street to key workers and the conversion of Parliament Place properties back into single family houses for sale on a shared ownership basis.
The terms were the subject of report numbers EDR/93/04 and EDR/107/04. These reports were withdrawn from consideration by the Executive Board when information was received suggesting the properties were to be re- offered for sale commercially by the potential purchasers
Internal Audit
A review of the negotiations and Cosmopolitan’s future proposals for the properties was undertaken and it was found that Cosmopolitan proposed to enter into a joint venture for the refurbishment of the properties and sale to owner occupiers which would not be exclusively for social housing. It was also proposed to transfer the leases from Cosmopolitan Housing Association to Cosmopolitan Commercial Limited.
Valuation
The opinion of the District Valuer was sought and the value of the Percy Street/Upper Parliament Street properties subject to the restriction was £200,000 and the open market value £1-1.3m.
The value of 1-9 Parliament Place subject to the restriction was £0-£100,000 and the open market value £1.25m.
Both valuations were dated 28 May 2004.
Dilapidations
The District Valuer has estimated that at the time of the valuation the costs of putting these properties back into repair at the end of the lease are c£300,000 for Percy/Upper Parliament Street and c£100,000 for Parliament Place.
District Valuer’s recommendation
At the conclusion of the review the District Valuer suggested putting the property to publicly advertised open tender, as this would guarantee best value and ‘transparency’.
Legal advice
Counsel’s opinion has been sought in respect of whether Cosmpolitan’s lease constitutes a business tenancy and would give rise to any rights to renew their lease under the provisions of Part II of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954. It is Counsel’s opinion that the lease does not constitute a business tenancy and therefore Cosmopolitan have no right to renew on expiry.
Next steps
Cosmopolitan still wish to renew the leases and refurbish the properties for key worker dwellings. However offering the properties for sale by tender on the open market will enable the Council to assess the offers received in terms of best price and best value as to their impact and contribution to the regeneration and stabilisation of the population in this residential area.
Cosmopolitan if they chose could also submit a tender.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.