Approval to go out to competition for Utility Coring Contract (Lee Lacking)
ApprovedCommittee1 paper
AI summarySalford City Council's Lead Member for Finance has approved going out to competition for a five year utility coring contract worth an estimated £450,000, funded by recharges to utility companies.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedOpen competition for utility coring contract
Money£450,000 over five yearsEstimated total, £90,000 per year, fully cost recoverable
What happens nextOpen tender under PA2023Decision comes into force 31 March 2026 unless called in
Who it affectsStreetworks team and utility promotersCouncil-wide contract for testing highway reinstatements
What was decided
Councillor Youd, as chair of the Procurement Board, approved going out to competition for the Utility Coring Contract, under the Council's Contract Procedure Rules via open tender. Report P1
The contract will run for over five years and costs will be fully recoverable by recharging failed core extractions to relevant promoters and following the NRSW defect process. Report P14
Why
The Streetworks team needs a UKAS accredited laboratory to test utility reinstatements on the highway. Early identification of non compliance helps keep Salford's road network in better condition. Report P2, P8, P13
Since Streetmanager began in July 2020, the council has issued 5,878 non-compliant inspections, 4,893 of which were reinstatement defects. After the two or three year guarantee period, the council loses power to enforce remedial works and would bear repair costs from highways maintenance budgets. Report P7, P20, P21
What happens next
The contract will be procured through open tender under the Procurement Act 2023, complying with the council's standing orders. Report P1, P34
The decision comes into force at 4.00 pm on 31 March 2026 unless called in, and was published on 24 March 2026.
The money
£450,000 Total estimated value of the five year contract Report P30
£90,000 Estimated annual value of the contract Report P30
£240 Maximum cost per failed core for statutory NRSW defect follow-up inspections Report P31
Options considered
Chosen: Procure the Utility Coring Contract through open tender. A time-served contract was identified as the way forward for this Lot, and open competition ensures value for money and reduces challenge risk Report P1, P27, P34
Implications
Financial: Contract is expected to be fully cost-recoverable. With a current fail rate of around 70%, the service generates an annual surplus; even at a 40% fail rate it would break even. Report P30, P31
Legal: Legal advice from Tony Hatton confirmed the competitive process will comply with public procurement legislation and the council's Contractual Standing Orders, minimising the risk of legal challenge. Report P25, P27, P28
Risk: If non-compliant reinstatements are not identified early, repairs after the guarantee period will fall to the authority and be paid from highways maintenance budgets. Report P20, P21
Equalities: No equality impact assessment was required for this decision. Report P18
Climate: No climate change implications were identified for this decision. Report P37
Who and where
Salford City Council Streetworks team, which will use the UKAS laboratory to test core samples on utility reinstatements Report P2, P8
Utility companies (works promoters), who will be recharged for failed core extractions and NRSW defect follow-up inspections Report P9, P14, P31
Highway users in Salford, who will benefit from better maintained road surfaces Report P2, P32
Timeline
11 February 2026: Legal advice obtained from Tony Hatton and procurement advice from Heather Stanton
23 February 2026: Financial advice obtained from Adam Flaherty
23 March 2026: Decision signed by Councillor Youd
24 March 2026: Decision published
4.00 pm on 31 March 2026: Decision comes into force unless called in
Over 5 years (contract length): Duration of the utility coring contract once awarded Report P14, P30
Plain English for the jargon
UKAS: UK Accreditation Service, the national body that accredits laboratories against recognised standards.
Coring: Taking physical core samples from road surfaces to test whether utility reinstatements meet the required specification.
Streetmanager: The government's digital permit scheme for street works in England, in use since July 2020.
NRSW: New Roads and Streetworks Act 1991, which sets the statutory framework for street works and reinstatements.
Reinstatement: The repair of a road surface after utility companies have dug it up to access underground services.
PA2023: Procurement Act 2023, the public procurement legislation under which the open tender will be run.
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item5d
Resolved
Salford City Council – Record of Decision I Councillor Youd, Lead Member for Finance and Support Services and chairman of the Procurement Board, accept the recommendation of the Procurement Board and in exercise of the powers contained within the Council Constitution do hereby approve: · to go out to competition for Utility coring contract. The Reasons are: The service give the Streetworks team a UKAS qualified laboratory to carryout core testing on Utility reinstatements. Options considered and rejected were: N/A. Assessment of Risk: After 2 or 3 years non-compliant reinstatements will become the responsibility of the Authority and any repairs will be borne out of the highway’s maintenance budgets. The source of funding is: fully cost recoverable. Legal Advice obtained: 11/02/2026 by Tony Hatton. Financial Advice obtained: 23/02/2026 Adam Flaherty. Procurement Advice obtained: 11/02/2026 by Heather Stanton. HR Advice obtained: N/A. Climate Change Implications obtained: N/A. The following documents have been used to assist the decision process: · approval to go out to competition for Utility coring contract. Contact Officer: Lee Lacking Telephone number: [email protected] Signed: Cllr J Youd Dated: 23 March 2026. Lead Member FOR DEMOCRATIC SERVICES USE ONLY: * This decision was published on 24 March 2026. * This decision will come in force at 4.00 p.m. on 31 March 2026 unless it is called-in in accordance with the Decision Making Process Rules.
Word for word from the decision Salford published for this meeting.Source: sccdemocracy.salford.gov.uk
That Procurement Board recommends (Councillor Youd, Lead Member for Finance and Support Services and chairman of the Procurement Board)/ (Paul Dennett, City Mayor), to grant authority for Utility coring contract to be procured in accordance with the Council’s Contract Procedure Rules through open tender.
Executive summary
The purpose of this report is to request approval to go out to competition for the delivery of the abovementioned service. The service will give the Streetworks team a UKAS qualified laboratory to carryout testing on reinstatements , poor or noncompliant reinstatements on the highway do result or certainly add to the deterioration on Salford’s network. Testing reinstatements gives us comfort that reinstatements will be undertaken to the correct specification, and in return make for a better road network.
BACKGROUND DOCUMENTS:
None
KEY DECISION: Yes
Sample A – going out to tender DETAILS:
Recent reports sent to department of transport ( DFT) from the start of Streetmanager ( a government digital permit scheme for England) July 2020, we looked at data from Salford CC and we have issued 5878 non-compliant inspections. 4893 are reinstatement defects. . The figures above are for inspections which have been undertaken within the guarantee period mainly within 2 years but in some cases 3 years. If there is deterioration after the guarantee period ends we have no powers to enforce remedial works.
As part of the asset management strategy the street works team undertake core sample testing on utility works to ensure long term compliance with the statutory specifications and to help with early identification of noncompliance.
This testing must be carried out by a UKAS Accredited laboratory. Where a core sample fails these tests, the cost can be recovered from the works promoter, otherwise the cost is borne by the Authority. The current rate of extraction is 20-30 cores per week and is based on performance of each promotor.
Throughout the tender stage we will be looking for the below qualities
Correctly accredited by UKAS National Accreditation Body for the United Kingdom, to undertake the testing we require.
• Proven track record of success • Competitive pricing • Social value is placed highly in their work ethos. • Successfully manages challenges
Over a 12 month period Salford CC receive average around 12000 permits to work on our highway. 70% of works require an asphalt reinstatement on our highway. Early investigations can be carried out on each reinstatement, 0-6 months Cat B inspection and 21-24 month CAT C inspections and very occasionally 32-36 month on deep excavations to identify noncompliance. However deterioration may only be present after the 2 or 3 year guarantee period has lapsed, as a result in many cases the local Authority would then need to undertake the remedial works themselves at our own cost. Early intervention in identifying noncompliance at early stages and key stages within the guarantee period, can stand Salford CC in a much better position to keep our network in a much more better and reliable condition.
Contract amount will be over 5 years, and cost will be fully recoverable a per recharging back failed core extractions to relevant promotors and following the NRSW defect process.
Sample A – going out to tender KEY COUNCIL POLICIES:
New road and Streetworks act 1991 and Salford CC Network management duties
EQUALITY IMPACT ASSESSMENT AND IMPLICATIONS:
N/A
ASSESSMENT OF RISK:
After 2 or 3 years non-compliant reinstatements will become the responsibility of the
Authority and any repairs will be borne out of the highway’s maintenance budgets.
SOURCE OF FUNDING:
See financial comments below.
LEGAL IMPLICATIONS: Supplied by: Tony Hatton
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.