CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Argyll and Bute Council
Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee, Thursday 18 December 2025 at 10.30am

UPDATE ON MEASURES TO PROTECT AGAINST ROCKFALLS ON B8035, GRIBUN, MULL

Noted Committee 2 papers

AI summaryArgyll and Bute Council's Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee asked officers to continue working with partners to identify a B8035 Gribun rockfall option. No option was chosen and no budget was set, with a further update due after a preferred option and costings are identified [D].

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeNotedNo option was selected at this stage [D]
MoneyNo budget set [D]Costings await a preferred option [D]
What happens nextFuture committee update [D]After preferred option and costings are identified [D]
Who it affectsB8035 road users at Gribun [P23]Rockfall risk remains under appraisal [P23][D]

What was decided

The committee noted the options set out in the submitted report [D].

Officers should continue working with partners to identify an option that keeps rockfall risk as low as reasonably practicable [D]. The comparison must weigh rockfall likelihood and impact against the cost of prevention [D].

A further update should go to a future committee once a preferred option and costings have been identified [D].

Why

The preliminary assessment places risk mainly on the boundary between unacceptable and tolerable levels, with some conditions likely to move it into the unacceptable range [P95][P156]. Report P95, P156

At 10 rockfalls per year and 20 journeys per day, risk for four occupant vehicles remains unacceptable [P84][P87]. Report P84, P87

Full slope engineering is likely to give the greatest risk reduction, but can take time and have substantial cost and technical challenges [P25]. Targeting higher risk areas may reduce risk more cost effectively [P26]. Report P25, P26

What happens next

Officers will continue working with partners to identify a preferred option and costings [D].

The report recommends reviewing the most appropriate two remedial options, or combined options, before setting a budget and consulting stakeholders [P158]. Report P158

A further update will be brought to a future committee as soon as a preferred option and costings have been identified [D].

The money

  • £500 000 Estimated cost for scaling the 500 m higher frequency area [P149][P154]. Report P149, P154
  • £1 million Estimated cost for rockfall fencing over the targeted 500 m [P125][P153]. Report P125, P153
  • £50 000 Estimated cost for scaling the initial road section with tight bends [P149]. Report P149
  • £2 million Estimated whole face light scaling cost, based on approximately £10 per square metre. Heavy scaling is expected to cost approximately £300 per m2 [P147][P154]. Report P147, P154
  • £3.6 million Estimated whole site rockfall fence cost, based on £2000 per m [P124][P153]. Report P124, P153
  • £20 million Estimated cost for stabilisation netting over the targeted 500 m [P133][P154]. Report P133, P154
  • £65 million Estimated whole site stabilisation netting cost, based on £400 per m2 [P132][P154]. Report P132, P154

Options considered

  • Rejected: Inspection and scaling, full slope or targeted areas. Not chosen at this stage. The committee did not rule it out and will continue option appraisal [D]. Regular scaling reduces the number of rocks reaching the road [P135]. The initial programme is slow, logistically complex and may extend beyond 12 months [P146][P147]. Report P146, P147
  • Rejected: Rockfall fences, full site or targeted 500 m. Not chosen at this stage. Targeted fencing is rated moderate for risk reduction and whole site fencing high [P153][P154]. Both need regular inspection, maintenance and removal of accumulated material [P126][P127]. Report P126, P127, P153, P154
  • Rejected: Rock stabilisation netting, full site or targeted 500 m. Not chosen at this stage. Targeted netting is rated moderate and whole site netting high for preventing detached rocks from reaching the road [P153][P154]. Both need regular inspection and maintenance after rockfall events [P153][P154]. Report P153, P154
  • Rejected: Road closure except for local access. Not chosen at this stage. It would limit public vehicle journeys, but at 10 rockfall events per year residual risk remains unacceptable for four occupant vehicles [3.1]. Gates and local risk information would be required [P99][P100]. Report 3.1, P99, P100
  • Rejected: Road closure during high rainfall events. Not chosen at this stage. It may reduce exposure during periods when rockfall is potentially more likely, but the relationship with rainfall cannot be confirmed [P102]. It would need monitoring, staffing, a site gauge and a management plan [P121]. Report P102, P121
  • Rejected: Reopen with additional signage. Not chosen at this stage. Additional signage is unlikely to reduce risk and is not expected to reduce the council's liability [P151]. Scaling and a legal review would also be recommended [P152]. Report P152
  • Rejected: Earthwork bund. Not considered further because a substantial bund would need to be 4 to 8 m high, construction at the toe would be problematic and substantial material would need to be imported [P122]. Report P122

Implications

  • Financial: The reported costs are approximate and should not be relied on for budgets [P97]. They must be revised at each design stage, and an accurate estimate would need a suitably qualified quantity surveyor or estimator [P97]. Report P97
  • Risk: The preliminary assessment places risk mainly on the boundary between unacceptable and tolerable levels, with some conditions likely to move it into the unacceptable range [P95][P156]. Report P95, P156
  • Risk: At 10 rockfalls per year and 20 journeys per day, risk for four occupant vehicles remains unacceptable [P84][P87]. Significant reduction in journeys or rockfall frequency reaching the road would be needed [P88]. Report P84, P87, P88
  • Climate: Climate modelling points to warmer winters, prolonged rainfall, hotter summers and more intense heavy rainfall [P92][P120]. Local effects were not assessed, so the change in risk remains uncertain [P93]. Report P92, P93, P120
  • Legal: Additional warning signage is not expected to reduce the council's liability if a serious injury or fatality occurs [P151]. The legal team should review road user safety implications and liabilities [P152]. Report P152
  • Staffing: Rainfall closures would require monitoring, personnel to close and inspect the road, and a management plan setting weather thresholds [P121]. Report P121
  • Equalities: The assessment says older people, people in more exposed vehicles and people travelling faster have higher vulnerability [P51]. Walkers and cyclists are also expected to have higher vulnerability [P51][P52]. Report P51, P52
  • Other: Scaling is likely to be slow and logistically complex because of access and workforce limits [P146]. The initial programme may extend beyond 12 months [P147]. Report P146, P147

Who and where

  • Road users on the B8035 at Gribun Report P23, P28
  • Older people and people with health vulnerabilities Report P51
  • People in exposed vehicles such as motorcycles Report P51
  • Walkers and cyclists Report P51, P52, P153
  • Local road users if access is restricted Report 3.1, P99
  • Single and four occupancy vehicle users Report P78, P82
  • Construction, inspection and scaling workers Report P129, P130, P150, P187
  • Argyll and Bute Council Report P126, P152

Timeline

  • June 2022: Average traffic was recorded as 330 vehicles per day [P56]. Report P56
  • 02/07/2025: Initial rockfall event. Between 0.1 and 7.0 mm of rainfall was recorded, with up to 25.6 mm in preceding days [P105]. Report P105
  • 06/08/2025: Second rockfall event. Between 6.0 and 15.3 mm of rainfall was recorded, with up to 31.1mm in preceding days [P106]. Report P106
  • 30/09/2025: Drone survey supplied the terrain used for rockfall modelling [P59]. Report P59
  • 10/10/2025: Interim appraisal published [P27]. Report P27
  • 12 November 2025: Final options report issued [P2][P11]. Report P2, P11
  • 30 November 2025: Officer report submitted to committee [D].
  • As soon as a preferred option and costings have been identified: Further update to go to a future committee [D].

Plain English for the jargon

  • ALARP: As Low As Reasonably Practicable. Risk in this range may be allowed if further controls would be disproportionate to the benefit [P73].
  • RAMMS: Rockfall modelling software used to estimate trajectories, velocities, bounce heights and kinetic energy [P58].
  • Quantitative risk assessment: A calculation of rockfall risk using hazard likelihood, elements at risk, vulnerability and exposure [P34][P36].
  • Rockfall barrier: A catch fence that intercepts and contains falling debris before it reaches the road [P123].
  • Rock stabilisation netting: A system that limits the frequency and volume of rock reaching the carriageway [P131].
  • Scaling: Inspection and removal of loose material from the rock face to reduce falling rock [P135].
  • Earthwork bund: A substantial earth barrier at the toe of the slope, assessed here at 4 to 8 m high [P122].
  • Geotechnical risk register: A record of geotechnical hazards and a method for managing them [P166].
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item19

Resolved

Decision The Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee: 1. noted the options outlined in Table 4.1, of the submitted report, and agreed that officers continue to work with partners to identify an option that keeps risk as low as reasonably practicable having regard to: i. the likelihood; and ii. the impact of any rockfall versus the cost of prevention; and 2. noted that a further update report would be brought to a future Committee as soon as a preferred option and costings have been identified. (Reference: Report by Executive Director with responsibility for Development and Infrastructure Services, dated 30 November 2025, submitted)
Word for word from the decision Argyll and Bute published for this meeting. Source: www.argyll-bute.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Argyll and Bute's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee, 28 pages

B8035 - Mull Rockfall Final Options Report

12 November 2025

B8035 GRIBUN ROCKFALLS - GEOTECHNICAL RISK MANAGEMENT

AtkinsRéalis - Baseline / Référence Notice This document and its contents have been prepared and are intended solely as information for Argyll and Bute Council and use in relation to B8035 Gribun Rockfalls – Geotechnical Risk Management

AtkinsRéalis UK Limited assumes no responsibility to any other party in respect of or arising out of or in connection with this document and/or its contents.

This document has 28 pages including the cover.

Document history Document title: B8035 - Mull Rockfall Final Options Report

Document reference: B8035 - Mull Rockfall Final Options Report

Revision Purpose description Originated Checked Reviewed Authorised Date 1.0 Draft for comment E Norris C Parry A Koe A Koe 03/11/2025 M Smith 2.0 Update following first E Norris C Parry A Koe A Koe 12/11/2025 draft

Client signoff Client Project B8035 Mull Rockfall Job number Client signature/date

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
B8035 Final options report: v2_ISSUEReport 28 pages DownloadRead as text
PDF
UPDATE ON MEASURES TO PROTECT AGAINST ROCKFALLS ON B8035, GRIBUN, MULLReport 7 pages Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

On this subject at Argyll and Bute

Search all
  1. UPDATE ON MEASURES TO PROTECT AGAINST ROCKFALLS ON B8035, GRIBUN, MULLThis decision
  2. Update on measures to protect against rockfalls on b8035, gribun, mullNoted
  3. Proposed management measures for marine protected areas and specific areas of conservationNoted

More from Argyll and Bute Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
9 Oct 2026 A816 bealach mor permanent solution updateDecision The Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee noted the following key points – 1. the £1.1m appr... Noted Open
9 Oct 2026 Review of public convenience estateDecision The Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee – 1. noted the findings of the updated baseline re... Noted Open
9 Oct 2026 Review of roads and infrastructure services updateDecision The Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee – 1. noted the progress to date on the RIS Review;... Noted Open
9 Oct 2026 Winter service policy 2026/27Decision The Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee – 1. approved the 2026/27 Winter Maintenance Polic... Approved Open
9 Oct 2026 Waste management updateDecision The Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee noted the content of the report. (Reference: Repor... Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies