What was decided
The committee approved consultation before the formal process for larger or more complex TRO proposals. Officers will review and map existing orders, consult elected members and Community Councils, invite public comments through sessions and online options, then seek local Area Committee approval. Report P9, P6
It approved four priority areas for addressing the TRO backlog: Oban; Dunoon, Sandbank, Kirn and Innellan; Campbeltown; and Bute. Report P10, P6
It noted that a further report would go to the March 2026 Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee with recruitment progress and indicative timelines for consolidation and outstanding priority TROs. It also noted that TRO resources would be added through the Roads and Infrastructure Service Review restructuring. Report P4, P5, P12
Why
The backlog includes more than 600 recorded TROs, with the earliest dating back to 1933. Officers cited over 100 outstanding orders and 25 orders in the current programme that had historically been unable to progress because resources were limited. Report P6
The number of new and amended TROs needing processing rose significantly since 2016/17, while resources did not increase. The report said the current resource level was insufficient and would not deliver progress without an enhanced team. Report P6, 5.0
Consultation before the formal process was recommended for larger or more complex proposals. It was recognised as best practice and was expected to minimise the risk of a legal challenge to implementation. Two additional officers, with areas assigned between them and TRO work as the focus, were expected to speed up progression and consolidation. Report P6
What happens next
For larger or more complex proposals, officers will review and map existing TROs, consult elected members and Community Councils, hold public sessions and accept online comments, then seek local Area Committee approval. Report P6, P9
The service will recruit the new positions, identify whether training is needed and report progress to the March 2026 Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee. The report will include indicative timelines for consolidating orders and progressing outstanding priority TROs. Report P4, P6
Work will focus on the four approved priority areas. On Bute, the proposal is to consolidate speed restrictions into one order and traffic management orders into one order. Report P6, P10
Options considered
- Chosen: Consultation before the formal process for complex proposals, with the statutory process for simple proposals. Officers said the statutory process was sufficient for simple orders. Consultation was recommended as best practice for larger or complex proposals and to reduce legal challenge risk. Report P6, P9
- Chosen: Officer priority areas for backlog work. Officers had prioritised Oban, Dunoon, Sandbank, Kirn and Innellan, Campbeltown and Bute. Report P6, P10
- Chosen: Additional TRO resources through the RIS Review restructure. The current resource level was insufficient, and additional officers were expected to speed up progression and consolidation. Report P6, P12, 5.0
Implications
- Financial: The increased team will be funded from existing resources as part of the RIS Review restructure. Report P6, P12
- Legal: The Traffic Regulation Orders Procedural Document requires updating for recent legislative changes. It must expand coverage to additional order types, pavement parking and engagement before the statutory process, and cover the impact of the Islands (Scotland) Act 2018. Report P6, 6.3, 6.11
- Risk: Engagement before the formal process was expected to minimise the risk of a legal challenge to implementation. The present backlog and order format would make a move to digital TROs extremely difficult. Report P6, 6.6
- Staffing: An increase in staff requires appropriate training and management. Recruitment depends on applicants' qualifications, and training could delay consolidation work by at least 6 months. Report P6
- Other: Engagement before the formal process should provide a better customer service. Report P6, 6.5
- Other: Additional posts and a division of areas would prepare the authority for a possible move to digital TROs. The report expected Scotland to follow England after an initial trial and once associated regulations were affirmed. Report P6
- Climate: Climate change was recorded as not applicable. Report 6.7
- Equalities: The Fairer Scotland Duty was recorded as not applicable. Protected characteristics were also recorded as not applicable. Report 6.8, P6
Who and where
- Local communities in Oban, Dunoon, Sandbank, Kirn, Innellan, Campbeltown and Bute Report P6, P10
- Road users subject to traffic restrictions Report P6
- Businesses affected by local traffic regulation Report P6
- Public transport services affected by local traffic regulation Report P6
- Elected members involved in engagement Report P6
- Community Councils involved in engagement Report P6
- Local Area Committees asked to approve proposals Report P6
- Argyll and Bute Council's Roads and Infrastructure Service Report P6, P12
Timeline
- 18 DECEMBER 2025: The committee approved the engagement method, four priority areas, future reporting and added TRO resources.
- March 2026: A further committee report will cover recruitment progress and indicative timelines for consolidation and outstanding priority TROs. Report P4
- at least 6 months: Training could delay the start of TRO consolidation works. Report P6
- 28 weeks: The minimum time to complete a straightforward TRO with no objections. Report P6
- up to 18 months: The process can take this long if objections cannot be resolved. Report P6
- 1933: The year of the earliest recorded TRO. Report P6
Plain English for the jargon
- Traffic Regulation Order (TRO): A legal order used to manage road user behaviour where a need has been identified. It can impose a wide range of road restrictions.
- Speed Order: An order that imposes speed limits on roads.
- Weight, Width or Length Order: An order imposing weight, width or length restrictions on the road network.
- Car Parking Order for an off street car park: An order setting conditions of use, including marked parking bays, payment and display, and time constraints.
- Disabled Bay Order: An order covering mostly on street disabled bays and a small number of other bays.
- Traffic Management Order: An order restricting street use, including one way systems, no waiting, on street parking controls and loading bays.
- Digital TRO: A possible future digital form of TRO. It was expected to become statutory in England after an initial trial and once associated regulations were affirmed, with Scotland anticipated to follow.
- RIS Review: The Roads and Infrastructure Service Review, which includes restructuring and added resources for TRO work.